www.christianitytoday.com Open in urlscan Pro
2001:1890:12bb:dea1::777  Public Scan

Form analysis
3 forms found in the DOM

GET /ct/search/

<form class="navbar-search spacer-left-35 js-searchForm" method="get" action="/ct/search/">
  <div class="input-addon-group d-flex align-items-center">
    <div class="autocomplete-container autocomplete-d js-autocomplete js-searchRsltSuggestion" data-suggestionindex="christianitytoday" data-valuefield="url" data-labelfield="title" data-searchboxtoggle="true" data-optioncount="3"
      data-bttntext="View All results" data-placeholder="" data-logic="AND" data-defaultfacet="language:English; NOT contenttypedisplayname:Sponsor" data-pub=""><select class="ais-autocomplete selectized" name="query" placeholder="" tabindex="-1"
        style="display: none;">
        <option value="" selected="selected"></option>
      </select>
      <div class="selectize-control ais-autocomplete single plugin-continue_editing plugin-preserve_search">
        <div class="selectize-input items not-full"><input type="select-one" autocomplete="off" tabindex="" style="width: 0px;"></div>
        <div class="selectize-dropdown single ais-autocomplete plugin-continue_editing plugin-preserve_search" style="display: none;">
          <div class="selectize-dropdown-content"></div>
          <div class="autocomplete-bttn" href="/ct/search/">View All results</div>
        </div>
      </div>
    </div>
    <input class="submit" type="submit">
  </div>
</form>

POST

<form class="js-recaptchaForm js-embedNL nl-embed-form" data-embed="true" method="post" target="_blank" data-nlurl="/system/newsletters/ajax/nl-subscription.html">
  <div class="newsletterFields"><input type="hidden" name="pageurl" value="/ct/1999/november15/neopaganisms-bewitching-charms.html"><input type="text" value="Email Address" name="email"
      class="nlField-email newsletterEmailInput js-emailInput clearField"><input type="submit" class="newsletterSubmitInput nl-signup" data-url="/ct/1999/november15/neopaganisms-bewitching-charms.html" value="Sign Up"><input type="hidden"
      name="label" value="Neopaganism’s Bewitching Charms"><input type="hidden" name="listID" value="30"><input type="hidden" name="targetID" value=""><input type="hidden" name="action" value="subscribe"><input type="hidden" name="nlsource"
      value="Christianity-Today-Inline"><input type="hidden" name="acNL" value="true"></div>
  <div class="recaptcha-widget" data-id="0">
    <div class="grecaptcha-badge" data-style="bottomright" style="width: 256px; height: 60px; display: block; transition: right 0.3s; position: fixed; bottom: 14px; right: -186px; box-shadow: gray 0px 0px 5px; border-radius: 2px; overflow: hidden;">
      <div class="grecaptcha-logo"><iframe title="reCAPTCHA" width="256" height="60" role="presentation" name="a-7vhzjvxy3iqt" frameborder="0" scrolling="no"
          sandbox="allow-forms allow-popups allow-same-origin allow-scripts allow-top-navigation allow-modals allow-popups-to-escape-sandbox allow-storage-access-by-user-activation"
          src="https://www.google.com/recaptcha/api2/anchor?ar=1&amp;k=6LdmqWwaAAAAAGL_sk4gXF1phZRERc7siyKAR8GG&amp;co=aHR0cHM6Ly93d3cuY2hyaXN0aWFuaXR5dG9kYXkuY29tOjQ0Mw..&amp;hl=de&amp;v=hfUfsXWZFeg83qqxrK27GB8P&amp;size=invisible&amp;cb=e6e7z4kukhwd"></iframe>
      </div>
      <div class="grecaptcha-error"></div><textarea id="g-recaptcha-response" name="g-recaptcha-response" class="g-recaptcha-response"
        style="width: 250px; height: 40px; border: 1px solid rgb(193, 193, 193); margin: 10px 25px; padding: 0px; resize: none; display: none;"></textarea>
    </div>
  </div>
  <div class="recaptcha-text">This form is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google <a href="https://policies.google.com/privacy" target="_blank">Privacy Policy</a> and <a href="https://policies.google.com/terms" target="_blank">Terms of Service</a>
    apply.</div>
</form>

GET /ct/search/

<form method="get" action="/ct/search/">
  <div class="form-group-inline flex-justify-center"><label>Search:</label>
    <div class="input-group"><input type="text" id="searchQuery" class="form-input form-input-sm" name="query"><input type="submit" class="submit" src="/ct/channel/img/btn_go.gif"></div>
  </div>
</form>

Text Content

Jump directly to the Content
 * About Us
   * Our Ministry
   * The Gap We See
   * Stories
   * Partner with Us
 * Newsletters
 * Give Now

Explore
 * About Us
   * Our Ministry
   * The Gap We See
   * Stories
   * Partner With Us
 * Newsletters
 * Give Now

 * My Account
 * Subscribe
   
 * Store
 * Log Out

Log In|Subscribe
 * Sections
    * Home
   
    * THE MAGAZINE
      
       * Current Issue
       * Issue Archives
       * Member Benefits
       * Subscribe
       * Give a Gift
       * Donate
   
    * SPECIAL SECTIONS
      
      * CT Pastors
      * News & Reporting
      * History
      * Podcasts
      * Videos
      * Español | All Languages
   
    * TOPICS & PEOPLE
      
      * Theology & Spirituality
      * Church Life & Ministry
      * Politics & Current Affairs
      * Higher Education
      * Books
      * Science
        Global ChurchUnityPolitics
      * All Topics & People
   
    * HELP & INFO
      
      * Contact Us | FAQ
      * My Account
      * Site Map
      * Store
      * Free Newsletters
        

 * Our Latest
 * The Magazine
    * Subscribe
    * Member Benefits
    * Give a Gift
   
   
   JULY/AUGUST 2024
   
   Digital editions:*
   Reader Friendly PDF|Standard PDF
   *Included with your Print + Digital Subscription
   View Current Issue
   
   
   ISSUE ARCHIVES
   
   Browse 60+ years of magazine archives and web exclusives. Subscribers receive
   full access to the archives.
   View Issue Archives
 * Subscribe
 * View All results


NEOPAGANISM’S BEWITCHING CHARMS

The movement rejects Christianity, but we may discover surprising openings for
the gospel.
Loren Wilkinson|November 15, 1999

1999
 * SHARE
 * post
 * Share
 * link
 * email
 * print

On the west coast of Canada, where my wife and I live, the Halloween cover of a
community newspaper pictured a smiling couple, both with long robes and flowing
hair, holding a pumpkin. The headline announced, "Wiccan Priest and Priestess to
Wed on All Hallow's Eve."

The lead story enthusiastically described the details of the wedding and
narrated the couple's pilgrimage to an "ancient faith" away from Christianity.
The bride said that after she became an atheist, "It seemed to me that creation
was sacred, the earth was sacred, and in the greater scheme of things we were
not outside of it, we were part of it."

The newspaper article reflects an undeniable aspect of contemporary life in
North America: the rise of neopaganism. Supporters claim it is the
fastest-growing religion in the United States, with nearly half a million
adherents. On the rural British Columbia island where we live, solstice
celebrations can be attended better than the local church. In the city yellow
pages, Wiccan is listed with Baptist, Presbyterian, and Catholic churches.
(Wicca comes from witch and means one who works with natural forces by shaping
or bending them. Thus, the word is closely related to wicker, not wicked.)

The thousand-acre forest that surrounds the university where I teach is called
"Pacific Spirit Park" and is described as "a ground for our becoming one with
nature." In many bookstores, large sections deal with magic, paganism, and Wicca
and are full of volumes by mainstream publishers with titles like The Pagan Path
and Voices from the Circle.

Interest in paganism is not limited to the West Coast, where some religious
flakiness is expected. The largest pagan group in North America ("The Circle
Network") is based in Mt. Horeb, Wisconsin. Neopagan sites are among the most
frequently visited on the Internet, and hundreds of seasonal festivals in
Britain and North America draw pagan celebrants. Many people are willing—even
proud—to be called pagans and witches.

When neopaganism is limited by the circle of the self, it can quickly make a god
of the self.

How should Christians respond to this growth of neopaganism? The two most common
responses are both wrong. The first response, with a long history in
Christendom, is to regard all forms of paganism as thinly veiled Satanism, a
worship of evil that Christians must oppose. This attitude led to what neopagans
often call "the burning times," when many witches, mostly women, were killed. It
is impossible to determine the numbers, but some neopagan claims reach into the
millions.

Article continues below



FREE NEWSLETTERS

Get the best from CT editors, delivered straight to your inbox!
This form is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of
Service apply.
More Newsletters

The other response, consistent with a growing acceptance of religious pluralism,
is to affirm the sincerity of neopagan spirituality. Since there are many
"mansions of the spirit," as the current Anglican bishop in Vancouver put it,
Christians should accept this form of spirituality as an authentic way to God,
just like our own Christian faith.

There are very good reasons to be concerned about the rise of neopaganism: most
fundamentally neopaganism, like all religions, is a dead end unless it leads to
a knowledge of God through Jesus. Neopaganism is particularly troubling when it
shows up in Christian churches, often as an accommodation to two closely related
themes in contemporary culture. The first is the beguiling idea that the only
God we need to pay any attention to is the god within, a thinly veiled way of
worshiping the self under the guise of "my own spirituality." It is a short and
fatal step from "finding God within" to an affirmation of the ancient lie that
we can ourselves become "like gods."

The second place where neopaganism shows up in Christian churches is in the
attempt to get rid of the inescapably masculine imagery for God in the Bible.
God is spirit, transcending gender, so it seems such a harmless and healing step
to refer to God as she instead of he, as Mother instead of Father, or as Goddess
instead of God. This opens a door to that confusion of creation and Creator
which is paganism's great mistake: to worship the earth itself as the great
immanent divinity that continually gives birth out of its own fertile mystery.
To equate God (or Goddess) and earth in this way is to deny the distinct and
transcendent personality of the God revealed in Scripture.

These are very real dangers that evangelicals need to oppose strongly. But if we
merely focus on the dangers, we will miss another, more hopeful strand of
neopaganism, an attribute of the movement that provides the key to our
evangelism.

AT HOME HERE

One of my first close contacts with neopaganism took place a few years ago when
my wife, daughter, and I were involved in a blockade protesting the logging of
the last large areas of old forest on the west coast of Vancouver Island. We
were persuaded to participate by a new Christian who was impressed by the
spiritual seriousness of the protest and the complete lack of any Christian
presence there.

Article continues below


We too were impressed—and bemused—by the spiritual intensity of the event.
Though most of the participants were younger than us, we were coached in
nonviolent resistance techniques by a grandmotherly, white-haired woman who said
she was a Wicca priestess—a witch. We were given song sheets that included hymns
to "the earth goddess," and sat in the big Circle (the name denoted not only a
shape but an event and an attitude) in a meeting conducted, we were told, under
feminist principles of "consensus and nonviolence." And there we planned the
next morning's blockade.

After the dawn arrests—by this time arrests had become almost a ritual—we
returned from our brief time in jail to the bright, late-morning light of "The
Circle." We decided to teach the group a song of our own, the words from Isaiah
55: "You will go out with joy, and be led forth in peace, and all the trees of
the field will clap their hands."

Many of the protesters seemed surprised that the words were in the Bible—as they
seemed surprised at the Scripture texts we had posted: "The Earth is the
Lord's," "Creation groans," and "in Christ … a new creation." But the biggest
surprise—always a pleased response—for this earnest group of protesters was that
Christians were even present at the protest. "Do Christians care about the
earth?" was a common inquiry.

A common tenet of neopagan religion is the belief that neither Christians nor
the Christian God are concerned or connected with the earth. To neopagans,
"Christian culture" seems to act as though the earth were merely raw material to
be used up in getting somewhere else (either to heaven or to a golden future).
Neopagans respond: We are at home here. Hence, the passionate protests to save
forests or to celebrate rituals that attempt to connect participants with the
cycles of nature.

For many people today, neopaganism is the result of a first, tentative response
to the word about God that is broadcast nonverbally through the whole creation.
Many neopagans are genuinely seeking God, and Christians need to see how the
neopagan thirst for spirituality and the sacred can be filled—not from the
stagnant pools of our own inwardness, but from the water of life that only Jesus
gives.

PUTTING THE “NEO” IN PAGAN

What is neopaganism? The neo is important. Even contemporary practitioners
recognize that they are trying to recreate something old, for their own
purposes, rather than carrying on an intact tradition from the past. For
example, a group called Arn Draiocht Fein (a Gaelic phrase meaning "our own
Druidism") describes itself as

Article continues below


> a completely independent tradition of Neopagan Druidism. Like our sisters and
> brothers in other Neopagan movements, we're polytheistic Nature worshipers,
> attempting to revive the best aspects of the Paleopagan faiths of our
> ancestors within a modern scientific, artistic, ecological and wholistic
> context.

Neopaganism is an eclectic religion characterized by what works and is appealing
now, not by faithfulness to an older tradition. As Starhawk, a well-known witch,
observed in an interview in Gnosis magazine: "It's unimportant whether
modern-day paganism is based on truth or myth. … It doesn't really make all that
much difference in terms of our relationship with the Goddess today."

Although references to "the ancient ways" abound in neopaganism, and many old
names are evoked, historical links evaporate when they are investigated closely.
Historicity doesn't matter, neopagans say: what's important is to create rituals
that express their experience of the sacred in the world and themselves.
Imagined links with an ancient tradition seem to help validate these rituals.

For many centuries the word pagan has had a double connotation for Christians.
Because it was long used to describe those who were not Christian, it has
carried a taint of wickedness and idolatry. More subtly, in the European world
the pagans were those who followed the old gods before their conversion, giving
the word an archaic ring. To be pagan was to be old-fashioned, behind the times.
Literally, however—and this is part of its current attraction—a pagan was a
peasant, a dweller in nature or the countryside, in contrast to the urban Roman
world. (A similar history lies behind the words heath and heathen.)

For good strategic reasons, Christianity first spread largely in the urban
centers. Paul (unlike Jesus) rarely preached in the country. The New Testament
was written mainly to city-dwellers. The peasants in the country were seldom the
first to become Christians; hence, the old pagan religions hung on longer there
than in the city. So country-dwellers were pagan in both senses of the word:
they were peasants and idolaters. By the late fourth century, when Christianity
had effectively become the official religion of the declining Roman empire,
pagan had assumed most of the negative tone it has carried until recent times.

Article continues below

Neopagans are sometimes accurate when they say that Christians turn their back
on the earth and its problems.

For many, the current fascination with paganism is the result of a reversal of
this ancient trend. As cities have grown, as the promise of a modern golden age
has faded, and as we have come to be more aware of our dependence on the natural
world, it is no longer a slur to be called a name that means country-dweller.
And in an age that is becoming less Christian all the time, it is certainly no
longer a slur to be called by a name which for so long has meant unchristian.

More important than its link to the past is the fact that paganism is not
Christianity. In fact, the non-Christian tone of the name is one of its main
appeals. Consider, for example, this self-definition on a well-designed neopagan
home page on the Internet:

> A neo-pagan is an individual whose interest in the religious sphere lies in
> patterns of belief which are non-orthodox and non-traditional in Western
> society and which more specifically pre-date Western society's dominant belief
> systems as represented, for example, by Christianity or Judaism.

Here the main feature of neopaganism is not any particular belief or practice,
but rather that it is non-orthodox, nontraditional, and is neither Christian nor
Jewish.

WORSHIPING GOD NATURALLY

Selena Fox, a Wicca practitioner from Mt. Horeb, Wisconsin, defines her belief
through an eloquent credo called "I Am Pagan." She begins by affirming her
participation in the cycles of nature: "I celebrate the changing seasons, the
turning of the Wheel of the Year." She then lists eight pagan festivals, all
with Celtic roots, such as Samhain (Halloween), Yule (the winter Solstice), and
Candlemas (Groundhog Day). At Samhain, the pagan new year, this wheel of nature
starts all over again.

This concern with half-forgotten seasonal festivals is not of mere antiquarian
interest. It is an attempt to be reconnected to the greatest harmony Fox knows,
that of nature.

Beneath the celebration of nature is an attempt to give meaning to the seasons
of her own life: "I also honor the seasons of life within my life's journeys:
beginnings, growth, fruition, harvest, endings, rest, and beginnings again. Life
is a Circle with many cycles . …"

Fox's frequent reference to circles, cycles, and wheels—with the circle being
the central neopagan symbol—reflects several important neopagan themes. The
first of these themes is the idea of the interconnection of all things (as in
the common "recycling" logo of three curved arrows).

Article continues below


Just as winter is linked through spring to summer and fall, so death is linked
to life, and the individual to the communal and universal. The idea is a
religious development of one of the key insights of ecological science: that in
the biological world everything is linked to everything else. Not only is it
impossible to study things in isolation from their environment, but it is
dangerous—if not impossible—for human life to proceed in ignorance of our
interdependencies with nonhuman things. The four seasons remind us of these
connections—hence the pagan seasonal festivals.

For neopagans, the circle has another dimension: it is non-hierarchical. Nobody
is at the head of a circle: all are equal. This explains the frequent close link
between neopaganism and some forms of feminism, which also question both
patriarchy and hierarchy.

The circle also connotes the idea of oneness and unity of all things (including
the self) with the divine. To quote Fox again: "I embrace Pantheism,
acknowledging that the Divine is everywhere and in everything. I honor divine
oneness, the unity of all."

Everything is included in this infinite circle of divinity: not only oaks,
herbs, rocks, and birds, but even (Fox's example) "my car, camera, and
computers." This explicit pantheism (or "monism") underlies the confessed
"polytheism" of neopagans, who are happy to invoke any god or goddess who might
be useful. Clearly the various deities they invoke (Artemis, Pan, Dionysus,
Thor, Isis) are regarded merely as masks or manifestations of the divinity of
all.

But in neopaganism the third, and perhaps most ominous, meaning of the circle is
the association of the "magic circle" with the self, the ultimate divinity, at
the power-wielding center. To quote Fox again: "My worship and rituals can be
anywhere since my sacred circle is portable."

In a sense, all persons are the center of circles carried with them always. Each
of us lives (to some degree) in a private world; we never have direct access to
another mind. But the "magic circle" in neopaganism is always for the purpose of
using power. And ultimately in neopaganism this assertion of the absolute
centrality of the self threatens the value and integrity of the other creatures
in that vast web of connectedness of which (pagans rightly say) we are a part.
Within one's "magic circle," only the self is divine.

Article continues below


Indeed, all the gods and goddesses of neopagan polytheism are ultimately only
manifestations of the self, given names drawn from the bubbling pot of world
mythology. No neopagan really expects to meet Artemis, Pan, or Satan in the
magic circle. The only god one will meet there is the self. Indeed, one fellow
islander admitted this frankly (if unintentionally) when he approached me about
reserving an unused stateroom on the ferry for a prayer room. "I like to pray on
these long trips," he said. "I need a place where I can get into myself."

The widespread idea that the only god that matters is the self, however many
names from old lore it might be given, is very dangerous. Here we come to the
fatal flaw in neopagan thought. Not far behind the idea that the self is divine,
Christians will recognize the old lie, the source of all sin: "You shall be as
gods." As Walker Percy has observed in Lost in the Cosmos, "two Gods in the
cosmos is one too many." A world of self-centered gods is not likely to be a
world of unity or relationship.

Not that such a dark possibility is the intention of any neopagans. We should
not make the mistake of equating neopaganism with the conscious pursuit of evil
or the worship of the devil. That would repeat the evil of the old
witch-burnings. Nevertheless, in this popular postmodern idea of the divinity of
the self, we see the fundamental divide between paganism and Christianity.

In response to a neopaganism that seeks to make all things (and especially the
self) divine, Christians must reassert the transcendence and otherness of God.
At the same time, we need to recognize the element of truth in the neopagan
recognition of God's immanence. Sometimes, ironically, Christians may need to
learn from neopagans that all of creation carries a divine message.

Neopagans are determined to say no to a modernity that declares the universe
(including ourselves) an accidental collection of atoms in which life, mind,
spirit, and God are illusions. Neopagans clearly reject a desacralized cosmos.
In its place they have tried to celebrate a re-enchanted cosmos where spirit,
mystery, beauty, holiness, and ceremony are central. In such a vision each thing
has value; nothing is merely raw material. This is surely closer to the biblical
view of creation than the current marketplace world where everything in creation
is a commodity to be bought and sold; yet many American Christians live in the
marketplace world with little tension.

Article continues below


SURPRISED BY LEWIS

A surprising voice in support of this kind of culture-questioning paganism is
that of C. S. Lewis. In all the praise of Lewis's superlative value as a
Christian apologist, not much is said about his cautious defense of paganism.
The old pagan world is implicit in nearly all of his fiction—from the thinly
disguised (but wonderfully baptized) Norse and Celtic world of Narnia, to the
ancient myth of Cupid and Psyche in Till We Have Faces, to the Greek-god-like
oyarsu in the Space Trilogy.

But Lewis is even more explicit in his affirmation of paganism as a way that
opens people to the true God. In Surprised by Joy, the story of his conversion,
Lewis wrote: "Sometimes I can almost think I was sent back to the false gods
there to acquire some capacity for worship against the day when the true God
should recall me to Himself."

His most explicit approval of paganism is in the early, allegorical account of
his conversion, Pilgrim's Regress. In that story, John, the main character,
seeks an island in the east—he is really seeking God, but doesn't know it
yet—and he encounters a hermit in a cave, who speaks with the voice of history.
The hermit explains that all the people in that country are estranged from God
(the Landlord), but that the Landlord keeps getting messages through about
himself. Often they come in pictures—what we might call mythology. He makes a
distinction between "the shepherd people" who had "the rules" (the Jews with the
revealed Law) and "the pagans" who had the pictures (mythology):

> The truth is that a Shepherd is only half a man, and a Pagan is only half a
> man, so that neither people was well without the other, nor could either be
> healed until the Landlord's Son came into the country . …

What Lewis suggests is that authentic paganism—a response, however confused, to
the rich and inarticulate mystery of creation—is part of the basic humanity
which ought to flourish and be healed in the new life of the gospel. As he puts
it even more vividly in the same section of Pilgrim's Regress:

> as often as men become Pagans again, the Landlord again sends them pictures
> and stirs up sweet desire and so leads them back to Mother Kirk [the Christian
> church] even as he led the actual Pagans long ago. There is, indeed, no other
> way. … That is the definition of a Pagan—a man so travelling that if all goes
> well he arrives at Mother Kirk's chair and is carried over this gorge . …

Article continues below


The same pattern is implicit in Scripture on those few occasions when Paul
addresses mainly pagan audiences. At Lystra, for example, Barnabas and he are
mistaken for Zeus and Hermes. And though he begs them to forsake as "worthless
things" the bulls, wreaths, and sacrifice of their ritual, he continues by
declaring that the very goodness of creation to which their worship is a
response is a gift of the one true God

> who made heaven and earth and sea and everything in them. … He has not left
> himself without testimony: He has shown kindness by giving you rain from
> heaven and crops in their seasons; he provides you with plenty of food and
> fills your hearts with joy. (Acts 14:15, 17, NIV)

Paul repeats the same theme in the more sophisticated Athens, going so far to
identify the "unknown god" of an altar with "the God who made the world and
everything in it … who gives all men life and breath," who "is not far from each
of us" and in whom, Paul says (quoting with approval a pagan poet), "we live and
move and have our being" (Acts 17:24-28). Paul's strategy is first of all to
affirm the divine gift and goodness of the cycles of creation—crops, sun, rain,
and the joy of being alive; and then to agree that the source of all that good
should be worshiped, not the gods of human invention, but the God who is
revealed in Jesus: "what you worship as something unknown I am going to proclaim
to you."

There is, of course, a great deal of difference between pre-Christian paganism
and post-Christian neopaganism. Part of neopaganism's attraction and very
self-definition is being over against Christianity. According to a questionnaire
published in a recent revision of Margot Adler's Drawing Down the Moon (by far
the best book on neopaganism), nearly 70 percent of those who call themselves
neopagans were raised in at least a nominal Christianity. Several of these cited
rejection of Christianity as their principal reason for becoming a neopagan.

But we need to be troubled by this neopagan rejection of Christianity. For when
we look at what neopagans think Christians believe, it becomes clear that they
are rejecting a caricature. One of the most common neopagan complaints is
against a distant Christian God, whom they see as a kind of emblem for
patriarchy, an aloof giver of laws, a cosmic killjoy. "The concept of divine
immanence," says one neopagan writer, "is completely lacking in
Judeo-Christianity."

Article continues below


Of course such a criticism is mistaken and misses the nature of the triune God
whom Christians worship. Yes, the Creator God is other than Creation. Yet
relationship—love and exchange—are central to God's nature. Central to the very
existence of each thing, says John, is the logos of God; indeed, says Psalm 19,
news about the words and deeds of God are proclaimed through creation to the
ends of the earth. Nothing would exist without God's continuous and self-giving
love. All things are created, says the psalmist, through the Spirit of God.
Scripture shows us a God who is personally, lovingly, sacrificially active in
the whole cosmos. The Creator of all things through Christ, in whom all things
hold together, is concerned also with the reconciliation of all things to
himself (Col. 1).

Yet it must be admitted that Christians often seem to worship a deistic, not a
Trinitarian, God: a God who created at the beginning, and who might occasionally
intervene in history, rather than the God of Scripture, who sustains our being
at every instant, and who (in Augustine's words) is nearer to us than we are to
ourselves. Christians need to show to the increasingly neopagan world more of
our experience of this God "in whom we live and move and have our being."

Neopagans are quick to point out the Celtic and pagan shadows in Christian
culture: the date and greenery of Christmas ("Yule"), the name of Easter, All
Saint's Eve (Halloween). But if indeed the gospel is about the self-revelation
of "the unknown God," once worshiped in ignorance but now made clear, those
pagan remnants in Christian tradition should serve to show the true relationship
of Christianity and neopaganism. The hints of divine meaning in the cycles of
the natural world are made clear in Jesus.

This relationship of the pagan and the Christian is symbolized well by that
best-known of Celtic symbols, the Celtic Cross—the cross superimposed on a
smaller circle. (Much of the language, imagery, and vocabulary of the neopagan
movement has been drawn from the pre-Christian Celtic world.) The image suggests
that only through the historic reality of the death and resurrection of Jesus
can the transcendent Creator be known. Then all the cycles and interconnections
of the created world (the circle) will be given their meaning in Christ, "the
Word without which nothing was made" who "became flesh and dwelt among us." The
larger cross over the circle suggests both the transcendence and the historicity
of the Incarnation.

Article continues below


When neopaganism is limited by the circle of the self, it can quickly make a god
of the self. Those pagan gods in the blood have risen again and again throughout
history, never more terribly than in this dying century. But when neopaganism is
open to Creation as a gift, it is open also to a relationship with that great
loving Other whom we meet in Jesus.

For those who already know God through Jesus, neopaganism is likely to be a door
out of relationship with God. (Sadly, I know some who have gone through that
door.) But for those who have been shaped by this secular age, neopaganism can
be at least a hallway toward the door that leads to the reality of the
transcendent and loving God. (Joyfully, I know some who have entered that way.)

Christians are "doorkeepers in the house of the Lord." Our challenge is to live
and speak so that we show the door to "the Unknown God," whom some neopagans are
genuinely seeking, is actually Jesus. Then they will find that the splendid,
tedious, and mysterious circles of our lives, and of all Creation, are given a
center and a meaning by the self-giving love of God which the Cross proclaims.

Loren Wilkinson is professor of interdisciplinary studies and philosophy at
Regent College, Vancouver, British Columbia. He and his wife live on an island
off the coast of the mainland. This essay is adapted from a forthcoming book,
Circles and the Cross, to be published next year by Paternoster Press.

Copyright © 1999 Christianity Today. Click for reprint information.





Have something to add about this? See something we missed? Share your feedback
here.




Our digital archives are a work in progress. Let us know if corrections need to
be made.

This article is from the November 15 1999 issue.


RECENT ISSUES

 * Jul/Aug
   2024
 * May/Jun
   2024
 * April
   2024
 * March
   2024
 * Jan/Feb
   2024
 * December
   2023

More Issues




NEOPAGANISM’S BEWITCHING CHARMS


Neopaganism's Bewitching Charms, Part 1 of 3
 * Sections
    * Home
   
    * THE MAGAZINE
      
       * Current Issue
       * Issue Archives
       * Member Benefits
       * Subscribe
       * Give a Gift
       * Donate
   
    * SPECIAL SECTIONS
      
      * CT Pastors
      * News & Reporting
      * History
      * Podcasts
      * Videos
      * Español | All Languages
   
    * TOPICS & PEOPLE
      
      * Theology & Spirituality
      * Church Life & Ministry
      * Politics & Current Affairs
      * Higher Education
      * Books
      * Science
        Global ChurchUnityPolitics
      * All Topics & People
   
    * HELP & INFO
      
      * Contact Us | FAQ
      * My Account
      * Site Map
      * Store
      * Free Newsletters
        

NEOPAGANISM’S BEWITCHING CHARMS

 * 
 * Subscribe
 * exit

Search:

 * SHARE
 * post
 * email
 * print

 * SHARE
 * post
 * Share
 * link

 * share
 * share

expand
 * email
 * print


UNLOCK THIS ARTICLE FOR A FRIEND

To unlock this article for your friends, use any of the social share buttons on
our site, or simply copy the link below.


SHARE THIS ARTICLE WITH A FRIEND

To share this article with your friends, use any of the social share buttons on
our site, or simply copy the link below.








Facebook

Twitter

LinkedIn
Social Sharing by Janrain

Share On Your Timeline
Shared on Your Timeline
Thanks for sharing with your friends on Facebook. Share with your other networks
too!

Start Over
x
+

4
Edit
Done
or browse friends

and 0 more
x
+
It appears the URL has been modified. Restore?
0
Edit
Done
x
+
It appears the URL has been modified. Restore?
0
Edit
Done

https://www.christianitytoday.com/ct/1999/november15/neopaganisms-bewitching-charms.html
undefined
Switch accounts
Connecting to Facebook failed. %TAG%View Error%GAT%

Share

Connect
Tweet To Your Followers
Prefer a direct message? Choose followers
Shared to Twitter
Direct Message your Followers
You can also tweet to all your followers
Sent to Your Followers
Thanks for sharing with your followers on Twitter. Share with your other
networks too!

Start Over
Select your followers
x
+

11
Edit
Done

Close
Done
Selected Followers
x
+

11
Edit
Done

Close
Done
x
+

4
Edit
Done
or browse followers

and 0 more
x
+
It appears the URL has been modified. Restore?
140
Edit
Done
x
+
URL will be shortened
117
Edit
Done

https://www.christianitytoday.com/ct/1999/november15/neopaganisms-bewitching-charms.html
undefined
Switch accounts
Connecting to Twitter failed. %TAG%View Error%GAT%

Share

Connect
Share With Your Connections
Shared to LinkedIn
Thanks for sharing with your connections on LinkedIn. Share with your other
networks too!

Start Over
x
+

4
Edit
Done
or browse connections

and 0 more
x
+
It appears the URL has been modified. Restore?
0
Edit
Done
x
+
It appears the URL has been modified. Restore?
0
Edit
Done

https://www.christianitytoday.com/ct/1999/november15/neopaganisms-bewitching-charms.html
undefined
Switch accounts
Sign in to your email providerConnecting to LinkedIn failed. %TAG%View
Error%GAT%Send email directly using your email client!Send email directly

Share

Connect