www.bbc.com Open in urlscan Pro
151.101.64.81  Public Scan

Form analysis
0 forms found in the DOM

Text Content

WE'VE UPDATED OUR PRIVACY AND COOKIES POLICY

We've made some important changes to our Privacy and Cookies Policy and we want
you to know what this means for you and your data.

 * OK
 * Find out what's changed


LET US KNOW YOU AGREE TO COOKIES LET US KNOW YOU AGREE TO COOKIES

We use cookies to give you the best online experience.

We use cookies to give you the best online experience.

Please let us know if you agree to all of these cookies.

Please let us know if you agree to all of these cookies.

 * Yes, I agree Yes, I agree
 * No, take me to settings No, take me to settings







Homepage


ACCESSIBILITY LINKS

 * Skip to content
 * Accessibility Help

Sign in
Notifications
 * Home
 * News
 * Sport
 * Weather
 * iPlayer
 * Sounds
 * Bitesize
 * CBeebies
 * CBBC
 * Food

 * Home
 * News
 * Sport
 * Reel
 * Worklife
 * Travel
 * Future
 * Culture
 * TV
 * Weather
 * Sounds

More menu
Search BBC Search BBC

 * Home
 * News
 * Sport
 * Weather
 * iPlayer
 * Sounds
 * Bitesize
 * CBeebies
 * CBBC
 * Food

 * Home
 * News
 * Sport
 * Reel
 * Worklife
 * Travel
 * Future
 * Culture
 * TV
 * Weather
 * Sounds

Close menu

What is BBC Future?

Future Planet

How to think about X

Follow the Food

Health Gap

Family Tree

Towards Net Zero

Best of BBC Future

Food Fictions

Latest

More


Loading
Psychology
How colours affect the way you think
Share using Email


Share on Twitter

Share on FacebookShare on Linkedin


(Image credit: Kan Taengnuanjan/Getty Images)

By Mark Ellwood14th July 2022

Our world is awash with a rainbow of colours, but certain shades can have a
surprising impact on our ability to concentrate, our mood and even the flavours
we experience.
A

A few years ago, a strange trend started to sweep through prisons in Europe and
North America. They began painting some of their cells pink. It became so common
that in 2014, one in every five prisons and police stations in Switzerland had
at least one detention cell that was painted a garish, flamingo pink.

The decor wasn't intended as an aesthetic choice or to make millennial offenders
feel more comfortable, but rather to leverage a well-known scientific study from
the 1970s. That's when researcher Alexander Schauss persuaded a naval
correctional facility to paint a few of its detention cells pink, theorising
from his own experiments that the colour might positively influence occupants'
behaviour, soothing and calming their agita. The results he achieved suggested
he was right – a memorandum written by the Bureau of Naval Personnel stated
confines needed only 15 minutes of exposure to the pink cell for their
aggressive behaviour and potential for violence to abate. Tests in other
detention centres appeared to back up his findings, and once they were published
in 1979 and 1981, the shade he used – initially made using a pint (473ml) of
semi-gloss red outdoor trim paint with a gallon (4,546ml) of pure white indoor
latex paint – began being deployed for its mood-changing properties in jails
around the world.

The pink tone – officially designated P-618 but called Baker-Miller Pink by
Schauss after the directors of the Naval detention centre he first tested it in
– has become known by various names around the world where it has been used,
from "Drunk Tank pink" to "cool down pink".

There's just one problem: Schauss' results have never been successfully
replicated. "There was a study in 2015, conducted in a proper way under
controlled conditions, that didn't find any evidence pink reduces
aggressiveness," says Domicele Jonauskaite, a colour researcher at the
University of Vienna, in Austria. A study at the Justizvollzugsanstalt Poschwies
in Switzerland involving 59 male inmates found that there was no difference
between white and pink prison cells on prisoner aggression levels.

Even if the apparent tranquilising affect of "Drunk Tank" pink is in doubt, the
readiness with which it was adopted speaks of something deep in the human psyche
about the power of colour. And it is perhaps not misplaced either – there is
evidence that colour can influence our behaviour in some surprising ways without
us realising.



Pink detention cells grew in popularity due to the belief that the colour could
help to calm aggressive inmates and reduce the risk of violence (Credit: Getty
Images)

For example, some colours can be used to compel us into taking action: see
research comparing the number of times a hitchhiker, whose vehicle had broken
down, was picked up by passing cars. When the stricken traveller – actually
played by one of the research team – wore a red shirt, she was picked up more
often than wearing other colours. Red has been shown to generate more immediate
emotional responses, though perhaps this is due to what's known as the
Berlin-Kay Theory, derived from the work of a pair of US academics in the 1960s.
Put simply, they found that red was always the third colour term to evolve in
the almost 100 languages they studied, after white and black. The longer a word
for a colour was in use, the greater the number of associations, meanings and
nuances it can acquire. In this way, the colour itself gains more impact.

Then again, colour can also be deployed to demoralise: one of the locker rooms
at the University of Iowa's football stadium was notoriously painted pink –
including the urinals – in an attempt to nibble away at the visiting team's
competitive spirit – based on Schauss's experiments. Exactly how effective it
was is still an open question – the statistics seemed to indicate that while the
pink room was in use, the Iowa Hawkeyes had a higher than average home win rate,
but there could be many other reasons for that record (they might just have a
better team, for example).

Much of the research on how colour can affect human behaviour is contradictory
though. Some studies suggest it can influence everything from our mood and
emotions to how fast our hearts beat, and even physical strength. Bright shades
of red, for example, have been found to lead to higher states of arousal and can
even stave off drowsiness. Experiments have also suggested that monotonous tasks
like proof-reading can be more effectively achieved in red offices while
creative tasks, such as essay writing, are better done in blue rooms. But other
work has shown that red and blue can also be distracting when trying to perform
tasks. Others suggest that certain personality types, such as introverts, might
be more susceptible to external influences such as the colour of their
surroundings.


> COLOUR CAN MESS WITH THE WAY WE EXPERIENCE SENSES SUCH AS TASTE AND FLAVOUR,
> OR EVEN OUR PREFERENCE FOR MUSIC

These contradictions have led some researchers to warn against placing too much
emphasis on claims about the therapeutic and psychological benefits of different
colours, saying there is still insufficient evidence to support them.

But there are some areas where colour has been found to have a clear influence
on our brains. For example, it can mess with the way we experience our other
senses, such as taste and flavour, or even our preference for music.

One thing that red seems to convey, fairly consistently, is sweetness. One study
of more than 5,300 people from around the world found that red-coloured drinks
were most likely to be regarded as the sweetest, no matter where the
participants came from.

Marie Wright, chief global flavourist at ADM Nutrition, a multinational food and
drink processor, recalls a particular product test for a strawberry flavour the
company had devised. Volunteers struggled to detect changes in sweetness as they
tested the flavouring. But when Wright and her colleagues brightened the redness
of the liquid rather than upping its sugar content, the participants began
reporting it was tasting sweeter.

You might also like:

 * Why happy music makes you do bad things
 * The words that change what colours we see
 * Why your favourite colour is probably blue

"We found that you can make something feel sweeter if it's brighter coloured,"
says Wright. "It's just like a bright red apple: before you've bitten into it,
you expect it to be sweeter." She says that brightening the colour can trick the
brain so much that it has allowed them to lower sugar levels in some recipes by
10-20%, although the results from these tests have not been published in any
academic journals to date.

It's important to be cautious around colours and nutrition, though – there is
some evidence that colour can alter how we experience food, but not necessarily
impact our consumption levels in the long term. Charles Spence, a psychologist
at the University of Oxford who studies how our senses interact with each other
and author of a book on the science of eating, says much of the crossmodal
influences between colour, flavour and mouthfeel come from ingrained social
associations we build up during our daily lives. Most of these come from
marketing and packaging, he says, but also from our experiences of foods we eat
day to day.

At first sight, one of these drinks will probably have seemed sweeter to you
than the other (Credit: Getty Images)

One thing is clear: we do indeed eat first with our eyes. When we see an
artificially coloured product, we confer all sorts of assumptions and
expectations on it before it gets anywhere near our mouths. We might expect a
bright blue ice lolly, for example, to taste of raspberry because we've been
trained to expect that from other ice lollies of that colour we have eaten
(interestingly Taiwanese consumers might instead associate a clear blue colour
with a mint flavour, while British youngsters would expect a raspberry flavour).
And when chefs or food companies play with that automatic association, it can
meddle with how we experience the food, says Spence. If the blue ice lolly
tastes of orange, it would likely take longer to identify that flavour. Whether
it can alter the intensity of the flavour we experience is still somewhat
disputed in the scientific literature, with some studies finding an effect, and
others not.

Another study looked at how the colour of a wine bottle label influenced the way
volunteers perceived the flavour of the red wine within: red and black labels,
for example, made it more likely that they would describe the wine as "tangy".

Strangely, colour can convey other types of sensual information too. Imagine an
advert for a towel pops up on this page – immediately, the softness is palpable,
almost as if you can feel it through the screen. But that perceived plushness
might not be down to high thread count you can see on the screen, it might be
its pastel colour, at least according to the work of Atefeh Yazdanparast, an
associate professor in the school of management at Clark University in
Worcester, Massachusetts.

"When I close my eyes, and think about softness, certain colours come to my mind
– they're usually lighter ones, light pink, light blue," she says. "That was the
question I had in my mind: what is the correspondence between our sense of
vision and our sense of touch?" Put simply, could colours convey softness or
hardness without hands-on experience?

So Yazdanparast and her colleague Seth Ketron, who studies consumer behaviour
and sensory marketing at the University of North Texas, ran some tests. They
asked volunteers to write down the colours they pictured when imagining softness
and, sure enough, they mirrored her own, skewing towards pale shades. Then the
pair asked volunteers to look at different colours, three at a time: each was at
the same saturation, or intensity, but they varied from light to dark. When
given adjectives to describe them, in 91.2% of the cases the lightest shade was
selected as the softest.


> THE DARKER THE COLOUR WE SEE, THE MORE INTENSE HAPTIC SENSATION – ATEFEH
> YAZDANPARAST

Although their findings have yet to be published and are undergoing academic
peer review as part of a larger scientific study, Yazdanparast cites similar
work with Turkish and Lebanese volunteers that produced similar
findings. Yazdanparast and Ketron studied American volunteers, so if their
results stand up to scrutiny, it suggests that softness may be a structural
association with lighter colours rather than a semantic, or linguistic, one.
"The darker the colour we see, the more intense haptic sensation," Yazdanparast
says. In evolutionary terms it could be that darker colours served as some sort
of warning to our ancestors, "priming them to be safe", she speculates.

Yazdanparast's broader work focuses on consumer decision-making, so she wanted
to see how these findings might be leveraged outside the laboratory. Again, she
and her colleagues devised a test, this time asking volunteers to look at
products on a screen in pairs – each the same colour, but one much lighter in
shade. Those products were deliberately items where haptics, or touch, might
prove important in purchasing decisions – think towels, bedsheets, sofas.

"We noticed that yes, the colour lightness results in higher anticipated
softness, which translates into higher purchase intention." Volunteers were also
willing to pay more for the objects they perceived as being softer.

What appears to be happening is that our brains are using colour as a visual
signal to compensate for touch. And it is employed to great affect by those who
want to sell us stuff – toilet roll, for example, is usually protected from our
hands by plastic packaging in supermarkets, but is almost always a light pastel
shade.

"90% of our initial product assessments are based on colour," adds Yazdanparast.

Colours can often have special significance and meaning in some cultures
(Credit: Getty Images)

But while pale shades may suggest softness, colour intensity suggests quantity,
according to Karen Schloss, a psychologist at the University of
Wisconsin-Madison and one of the world's foremost colour researchers. She has
helped to devise the ecological valence theory for why we favour certain colours
over others. She points to legends on data graphs, or maps: the colours chosen –
more specifically, their intensity – might be intended to use that association
to manipulate how you interpret that information. "People infer that darker
colours map to larger quantities, which has been used very well in most of the
pandemic maps I've seen – more cases, or fatalities, represented with darker
colours," she says, citing her own work as well as that of others on how we're
behaviourally conditioned to make that link.

Associations like this can lead to problems, Schloss warns. If data is presented
in a way that uses lighter colours for larger quantities, it can lead people to
misunderstand what they are seeing. If a map comes up on a screen for a split
second, "you're going to interpret dark is more, not light is more", even if
that isn't what the data really shows, she says.

But Schloss has also shown that colour can be used for good too – such as
encouraging better civic behaviour. Her recent research has delved into the
meanings we ascribe to colours. "We wanted to understand how people's
association with colour influences their expectations – so we could anticipate
them, and design to match them, and so make it easier to interpret," she says.

Colours are often used to help convey information about which recycling bins
rubbish should be sorted into (Credit: DonSmith/Alamy)

She and her colleagues used recycling bins as the basis of a particular
experiment.

Imagine six such bins, identical in size and shape, but each earmarked for a
different category with signs that read "glass", "metal", "compost" and so on.
Schloss posited that changing the colour of a bin might subtly telegraph its
purpose, helping to streamline behaviour and minimise mistakes in sorting. When
she and her team showed volunteers images of six differently coloured bins and
asked to label them as they saw fit, a pattern emerged. Some colours were
closely associated with a category: browns and yellows instantly suggested
trash, for example. Others, though, were more weakly associated: red, for
instance, didn't instantly evoke any category. There was, however, a slight
preference to label red bins with "plastic" when asked to choose among the six.

The meaning of colour, then, is contextual, Schloss continues. A single white
bin might obviously suggest paper, while a single red bin would mean little.
Taken together, though, a series of six differently coloured trash cans can play
off each other, and communicate far more, and more subtly.

Other studies have shown that colours can directly impact performance,
especially among children. When eight- and nine-years-olds conducted a series of
tasks in the presence of different shades, academics found their overall
performance was significantly worse around red versus grey, which was used as a
baseline. And forget blue-sky thinking, try green-space thinking – at least if
one study into creativity is credible, which showed a correlation between
creativity among children and the presence of that colour, or objects of that
colour such as plants. And if you want a child to concentrate, you might
consider painting a classroom in a vivid palette and so bolster their reading
scores.

"It all suggests colour is far more powerful than we thought," says Schloss.

--

Join one million Future fans by liking us on Facebook, or follow us on Twitter
or Instagram.

If you liked this story, sign up for the weekly bbc.com features newsletter,
called "The Essential List" – a handpicked selection of stories from BBC Future,
Culture, Worklife, Travel and Reel delivered to your inbox every Friday.

Share using Email


Share on Twitter

Share on FacebookShare on Linkedin

Share


RECOMMENDED ARTICLES

 * The Health Gap: How common are female psychopaths?
 * Family Tree: How to teach children about risk
 * How To Think About X: Why some people are overlooked geniuses
 * future: The weird effect language has on time

Around the BBC

Culture
Is this 2023's big Oscar-winner?


Worklife
'I regret the role, not my daughter'


travel
Pakistan's lost city of 40,000 people




EXPLORE THE BBC

 * Home
 * News
 * Sport
 * Weather
 * iPlayer
 * Sounds
 * Bitesize
 * CBeebies
 * CBBC
 * Food

 * Home
 * News
 * Sport
 * Reel
 * Worklife
 * Travel
 * Future
 * Culture
 * TV
 * Weather
 * Sounds

 * Terms of Use
 * About the BBC
 * Privacy Policy
 * Cookies
 * Accessibility Help
 * Parental Guidance
 * Contact the BBC
 * BBC emails for you
 * Advertise with us
 * AdChoices / Do Not Sell My Info

Copyright © 2022 BBC. The BBC is not responsible for the content of external
sites. Read about our approach to external linking.