www.americanbanker.com
Open in
urlscan Pro
18.165.183.101
Public Scan
URL:
https://www.americanbanker.com/opinion/dont-classify-earned-wage-access-programs-as-consumer-loans
Submission: On August 15 via manual from HK — Scanned from DE
Submission: On August 15 via manual from HK — Scanned from DE
Form analysis
1 forms found in the DOMhttps://www.americanbanker.com/search#nt=navsearch
<form class="Page-header-search-form" action="https://www.americanbanker.com/search#nt=navsearch" novalidate="" autocomplete="off"> <label> <input placeholder="Find your interests" type="text" class="Page-header-search-input" name="q"
required="true"> <span class="sr-only">Search Query</span> <button type="submit" class="Page-header-search-submit"> <svg>
<use xlink:href="#icon-magnify"></use>
</svg> <span class="sr-only">Submit Search</span> </button> </label> </form>
Text Content
Author Log In Subscribe * Banking * Commercial * Consumer * Community * Industry & People News * M&A * Small business * Earnings * Bank Industry Data * Commercial * Consumer * Community * Industry & People News * M&A * Small business * Earnings * Bank Industry Data * POLICY * Politics & policy * Regulation & compliance * Federal Reserve * CFPB * Fraud * Politics & policy * Regulation & compliance * Federal Reserve * CFPB * Fraud * PAYMENTS * Payments Home * Cryptocurrency * Digital payments * Credit cards * Payments Home * Cryptocurrency * Digital payments * Credit cards * TECH * Technology * Digital banking * Fintech * Cyber security * Artificial intelligence * Advances in Tech * Technology * Digital banking * Fintech * Cyber security * Artificial intelligence * Advances in Tech * CREDIT UNIONS * Credit Unions Home * Opinion * Credit Unions Home * Opinion * WORKPLACE * Workforce management * Recruiting * Diversity & equality * ESG * Compensation * Workforce management * Recruiting * Diversity & equality * ESG * Compensation * OPINION Follow Us In Real Time * twitter * facebook * linkedin © 2023 Arizent. All rights reserved. Menu Show Search Search Query Submit Search Log In Subscribe * Banking * Commercial * Consumer * Community * Industry & People News * M&A * Small business * Earnings * Bank Industry Data * POLICY * Politics & policy * Regulation & compliance * Federal Reserve * CFPB * Fraud * PAYMENTS * Payments Home * Cryptocurrency * Digital payments * Credit cards * TECH * Technology * Digital banking * Fintech * Cyber security * Artificial intelligence * Advances in Tech * CREDIT UNIONS * Credit Unions Home * Opinion * WORKPLACE * Workforce management * Recruiting * Diversity & equality * ESG * Compensation * OPINION * Women in Banking * Leaders Forum * Events * Research * Podcasts * Webinars and Whitepapers * Magazine * Jobs Payments BankThink DON'T CLASSIFY EARNED WAGE ACCESS PROGRAMS AS CONSUMER LOANS By Penny Lee June 20, 2023, 1:26 p.m. EDT 4 Min Read * Facebook * Twitter * LinkedIn * Email California regulators are suggesting that programs that allow workers fee-free access to their earnings between pay periods should be treated as loan products. That's wrong and short-sighted, writes Penny Lee of the D.C.-based Financial Technology Association. Montri - stock.adobe.com For the more than 50 percent of Americans living paycheck to paycheck, the end of the month is a stressful time. Making ends meet and managing bills like utilities, rent or car payments can often mean dipping into savings, over-drafting on a bank account or even as a last resort turning to predatory payday loans. These scenarios hurt workers and also propagate a broken model where others profit by extracting exorbitant fees or snaring consumers into ongoing debt traps. But now, technology-driven innovation is changing the equation with a better deal. Earned wage access, or EWA, fulfills a basic promise to American workers: If you worked today, you should be able to get paid today. You should have control of your wages and not have to go into debt because your employer only processes payroll once or twice a month. Earned wage access allows workers to access funds based on earned wages that have not yet been deposited into their accounts. Today, millions of Americans benefit from the flexibility EWA provides to manage their bills while waiting on a paycheck. Now, we need a regulatory framework that appropriately reflects the unique structure of EWA products and works for the families who rely on them. Currently, California's Department of Financial Protection and Innovation (DFPI) is considering new requirements for EWA that could set the stage for future national conversations. While the DFPI's proposal includes constructive measures like a registry to bring providers into a regulatory framework, other aspects could effectively limit competition and access to EWA. Credit unions Credit union loans fueled by growth in auto sales, home equity Total loans from credit unions increased by nearly 18%, driven in part by car dealerships rebuilding their inventory. Headwinds in the mortgage market also fueled interest in home equity loans. By Ken McCarthy June 14 Specifically, California is proposing to classify EWA as a loan even though several other state and federal regulators have recognized that EWA is not a form of credit. Legislatures in Missouri and Nevada recently passed comprehensive EWA legislation establishing a framework tailored to its risks and benefits and exempting EWA from lending laws. In addition, several other states recognize that lending laws are not suitable for EWA products and are considering their own EWA-specific frameworks. California's approach is out of step, and worse, a conflict in legal approaches across the states will create regulatory uncertainty and confusion and have the de facto impact of limiting product innovation and consumer choice. Instead, California should follow the path of other states and defer these policy deliberations to the legislature. Here's why: Getting paid for the work you have already completed should not count as a loan or a line of credit. EWA stands apart from credit products because it is nonrecourse, meaning customers do not face lawsuits or debt collection; in the event of nonpayment, companies pause service until users can repay — it's as simple as that. There are no late fees, no interest rates, no evaluation of creditworthiness and no impact on a consumer's credit score with an EWA product. According to a recent Federal Reserve survey, nearly four in 10 Americans couldn't cover a $400 emergency expense. Workers benefit from early access to their wages to confidently manage their finances, whether balancing bills at the end of the month or weathering a short-term financial shock like a hospital bill or car repair. Earned wage access also benefits members of the growing gig economy, estimated to make up 36 percent of the American workforce and the nearly half of American workers that are employed by small-to-medium size businesses, by offering a direct-to-consumer model so that anyone, regardless of their employer or employment type, can access their wages on demand. What's more, survey data makes clear EWA products are popular and working well for the millions of Americans who already use them. According to a recent survey, 93 percent say EWA makes them feel more in control of their finances, and 81 percent say it is the best option to manage their spending. Take workers like Cesar, who uses EWA to tap into his wages at a grocery retailer in San Bernardino County, California, and find financial flexibility. Cesar says that earned wage access "has helped me remain in good standing with utility providers, which include my daily essentials such as water, electricity and gas." Without EWA services, Cesar says, "I [would] struggle to make ends meet, and having to pay high-interest rate loans would worsen my economic situation." At the Financial Technology Association, we recently outlined a proactive view that would help consumers maintain access to EWA and continue to benefit from financial technology innovation that lowers costs, increases choice and drives competition. When an innovative product is working well for consumers, regulators should proceed cautiously to avoid actions that might inadvertently stifle innovation and harm consumers. It is not necessary nor helpful for DFPI to go further and declare these innovative products as credit or loans, thereby squeezing a square peg in a round hole. Collectively, we can get it right on EWA and other consumer-friendly financial products by taking the same approach as companies operating in this space and putting the customer first. Penny Lee CEO, Financial Technology Association. For reprint and licensing requests for this article, click here. Payments Earnings Debt Payday lending Innovation Compensation Lending TRENDING * The Most Powerful Women in Banking: Next 2023 Our annual list of 15 rising stars in banking and finance. * The Most Influential Women in Payments: Next, 2023 American Banker is proud to recognize, in its third annual Most Influential Women in Payments, Next, the women under 40 who have demonstrated expertise, leadership skills and an ability to adapt in an ever-changing payments industry. * 20 banks and thrifts with the most deposits at the end of Q1 The top five banks and thrifts have more than $7 trillion in combined total deposits as of the end of Q1 2023. MORE FROM AMERICAN BANKER GRUENBERG: LONG TERM DEBT, UNINSURED DEPOSIT REFORM COMING FOR BIG BANKS Federal Deposit Insurance Corp. chair Martin Gruenberg said Monday that the agency is not backing down on its Basel III capital proposal, and wants to implement long term debt requirements and adjustments to the living wills and uninsured deposit rules. Aug 14, 2023 U.S. BANCORP'S CEO, OTHER TOP OFFICIALS SUED OVER UNAUTHORIZED ACCOUNTS Chief Executive Andy Cecere is among the defendants in a shareholder lawsuit that alleges that top officials at the Minneapolis bank profited from the concealment of employee misconduct. A U.S. Bancorp spokesperson denied the allegations. Aug 12, 2023 REGULATOR: FAILED KANSAS BANK 'VICTIM OF A SCAM' Kansas Banking Commissioner David Herndon told American Banker that his agency declared Heartland Tri-State Bank insolvent because of a "very sudden" event that crippled the bank financially. Aug 4, 2023 BANKERS HATE SAYING 'ESG' BUT ARE HARDWIRING IT INTO FINANCE About two-thirds of respondents in a survey of roughly 300 Bloomberg terminal users said the anti-ESG movement that started in the U.S. last year will force firms to stop using those three letters in conversations with clients. Aug 14, 2023 FDIC: OFFICE LOANS, NONBANK FINANCING, CYBERSECURITY ARE TOP BANK RISKS In its annual report, the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp. explored the various credit, market and operational risks facing the banking sector. It also explored crypto and climate issues. Aug 14, 2023 CREDIT CARD BALANCES HIT $1 TRILLION. HERE'S WHY BANKERS REMAIN UPBEAT. U.S. consumers set a new record during the second quarter, as card debt reached $1.03 trillion. Bankers say a healthy job market has allowed consumers to keep making their monthly payments, but they're also on guard about the impact of the upcoming resumption of federal student loan payments. Aug 9, 2023 REDLINING TO REMEDIATION Last year's racially motivated mass shooting in a Black community in Buffalo, New York, has sparked discussions about whether banks need to right some past wrongs — including redlining — that left such neighborhoods segregated and impoverished. Subscribe Follow Us In Real Time * googlenews * twitter * applenews * facebook * linkedin * * About Us * Contact Us * The Magazine * Banker's Glossary * * RSS Feed * Privacy Policy * Subscription Agreement * Content Licensing/Reprints * Advertising/Marketing Services © 2023 Arizent. All rights reserved. © 2023 Arizent. All rights reserved.