www.wsj.com Open in urlscan Pro
2600:9000:2090:5800:3:4b0:de80:93a1  Public Scan

Submitted URL: https://sales.denodo.com/t/9886/c/bfe3d91f-1b4a-4a2f-bb7b-5d6c58b7a3f2/NB2HI4DTHIXS653XO4XHO43KFZRW63JPMFZHI2LDNRSXGL3UOJ...
Effective URL: https://www.wsj.com/articles/truck-drivers-bear-big-burden-on-data-collection-some-companies-want-to-change-that-37f...
Submission: On September 19 via manual from US — Scanned from DE

Form analysis 0 forms found in the DOM

Text Content

Skip to Main ContentSkip to Search
Skip to...
Select
 * Conversation
 * What to Read Next
 * Most Popular News
 * Sponsored Offers
 * Most Popular Opinion
 * Recommended Videos

DJIA34391.28points with a0.67%▼
S&P 5004424.27 points with a0.66%▼
Nasdaq13589.84 points with a0.88%▼
U.S. 10 Yr-3/32with a4.345%▼
Crude Oil92.57 points with a1.19%▲
Euro1.0693 points with a0.01%▲

Truck Drivers Bear Big Burden on Data Collection. Some Companies Want to Change
That.

Share
Resize
8

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------



Listen

(2 min)




SubscribeSign In
SubscribeSign In
SubscribeSign In

 * English Edition
   
   EditionEnglish中文 (Chinese)日本語 (Japanese)
   
 * Print Edition
 * Video
 * Audio
 * Latest Headlines
 * More
   
   MoreOther Products from WSJBuy Side from WSJWSJ ShopWSJ Wine
   

 * World
   Topics
   Africa
   Americas
   Asia
   China
   Europe
   Middle East
   India
   Oceania
   Russia
   U.K.
   More
   World Video
 * Business
   Topics
   Airlines
   Autos
   C-Suite
   Deals
   Earnings
   Energy & Oil
   Entrepreneurship
   Telecom
   Retail
   Hospitality
   Logistics
   Media
   C-Suite
   CFO Journal
   CIO Journal
   CMO Today
   Logistics Report
   Risk & Compliance
   The Workplace Report
   WSJ Professional
   WSJ Pro Bankruptcy
   WSJ Pro Central Banking
   WSJ Pro Cybersecurity
   WSJ Pro Private Equity
   WSJ Pro Sustainable Business
   WSJ Pro Venture Capital
   More
   Heard on the Street
   Management
   Journal Reports
   Business Video
   Business Podcast
 * U.S.
   Topics
   Climate & Environment
   Education
   Law
   College Rankings 2024
   More
   U.S. Video
   What's News Podcast
 * Politics
   Topics
   Elections
   National Security
   Policy
   More
   Politics Video
 * Economy
   Topics
   Central Banking
   Consumers
   Housing
   Jobs
   Trade
   Global
   WSJ Professional
   WSJ Pro Bankruptcy
   WSJ Pro Central Banking
   WSJ Pro Private Equity
   WSJ Pro Venture Capital
   More
   Capital Account
   Economic Forecasting Survey
   Economy Video
 * Tech
   Topics
   AI
   Biotech
   Cybersecurity
   Personal Technology
   More
   Christopher Mims
   Joanna Stern
   Julie Jargon
   Nicole Nguyen
   CIO Journal
   The Future of Everything
   Tech Video
   Tech Podcast
 * Finance
   Topics
   Banking
   Commodities & Futures
   Currencies
   Investing
   Regulation
   Stocks
   More
   Heard on the Street
   Greg Ip
   Jason Zweig
   Laura Saunders
   James Mackintosh
   CFO Journal
   Markets Video
   Your Money Briefing Podcast
   Market Data
   Market Data Home
   Companies
   U.S. Stocks
   Commodities
   Bonds & Rates
   Currencies Market Data
   Mutual Funds & ETFs
 * Opinion
   Columnists
   Gerard Baker
   Sadanand Dhume
   Allysia Finley
   James Freeman
   William A. Galston
   Daniel Henninger
   Holman W. Jenkins
   Andy Kessler
   William McGurn
   Walter Russell Mead
   Peggy Noonan
   Mary Anastasia O'Grady
   Jason Riley
   Joseph Sternberg
   Kimberley A. Strassel
   More
   Editorials
   Commentary
   Future View
   Houses of Worship
   Cross Country
   Letters to the Editor
   The Weekend Interview
   Potomac Watch Podcast
   Foreign Edition Podcast
   Free Expression Podcast
   Opinion Video
   Notable & Quotable
 * Arts & Culture
   Topics
   Books
   Film
   Fine Art
   Food & Cooking
   History
   Music
   Television
   Theater
   Reviews
   Film Reviews
   Television Reviews
   Theater Reviews
   Masterpiece Series
   Music Reviews
   Dance Reviews
   Opera Reviews
   Exhibition Reviews
   Cultural Commentary
   More
   WSJ Puzzles
   What To Watch
   Arts Calendar
 * Lifestyle
   Topics
   Careers
   Cars
   Fitness
   Relationships
   Travel
   Workplace
   More
   On Wine
   Work & Life
   Carry On
   On The Clock
   Elizabeth Bernstein
   Turning Points
   WSJ Puzzles
   Recipes
 * Real Estate
   Topics
   Commercial Real Estate
   Luxury Homes
 * Personal Finance
   Topics
   Retirement
   Savings
   Credit
   Taxes
   Mortgages
   More
   Jason Zweig
   Laura Saunders
   James Mackintosh
 * Health
   Topics
   Healthcare
   Pharma
   Wellness
   More
   Your Health
 * Science
   Topics
   Archaeology
   Biology
   Environment
   Physics
   Space & Astronomy
   More
   The Future of Everything
 * Style
   Topics
   Beauty
   Design
   Fashion
   More
   Off Brand
   On Trend
   My Monday Morning
 * Sports
   Topics
   Baseball
   Basketball
   Football
   Golf
   Hockey
   Olympics
   Soccer
   Tennis
   More
   Jason Gay


SubscribeSign In

 * English Edition
   
   EditionEnglish中文 (Chinese)日本語 (Japanese)
   
 * Print Edition
 * Video
 * Audio
 * Latest Headlines
 * More
   
   MoreOther Products from WSJBuy Side from WSJWSJ ShopWSJ Wine
   

 * World
   Topics
   Africa
   Americas
   Asia
   China
   Europe
   Middle East
   India
   Oceania
   Russia
   U.K.
   More
   World Video
 * Business
   Topics
   Airlines
   Autos
   C-Suite
   Deals
   Earnings
   Energy & Oil
   Entrepreneurship
   Telecom
   Retail
   Hospitality
   Logistics
   Media
   C-Suite
   CFO Journal
   CIO Journal
   CMO Today
   Logistics Report
   Risk & Compliance
   The Workplace Report
   WSJ Professional
   WSJ Pro Bankruptcy
   WSJ Pro Central Banking
   WSJ Pro Cybersecurity
   WSJ Pro Private Equity
   WSJ Pro Sustainable Business
   WSJ Pro Venture Capital
   More
   Heard on the Street
   Management
   Journal Reports
   Business Video
   Business Podcast
 * U.S.
   Topics
   Climate & Environment
   Education
   Law
   College Rankings 2024
   More
   U.S. Video
   What's News Podcast
 * Politics
   Topics
   Elections
   National Security
   Policy
   More
   Politics Video
 * Economy
   Topics
   Central Banking
   Consumers
   Housing
   Jobs
   Trade
   Global
   WSJ Professional
   WSJ Pro Bankruptcy
   WSJ Pro Central Banking
   WSJ Pro Private Equity
   WSJ Pro Venture Capital
   More
   Capital Account
   Economic Forecasting Survey
   Economy Video
 * Tech
   Topics
   AI
   Biotech
   Cybersecurity
   Personal Technology
   More
   Christopher Mims
   Joanna Stern
   Julie Jargon
   Nicole Nguyen
   CIO Journal
   The Future of Everything
   Tech Video
   Tech Podcast
 * Finance
   Topics
   Banking
   Commodities & Futures
   Currencies
   Investing
   Regulation
   Stocks
   More
   Heard on the Street
   Greg Ip
   Jason Zweig
   Laura Saunders
   James Mackintosh
   CFO Journal
   Markets Video
   Your Money Briefing Podcast
   Market Data
   Market Data Home
   Companies
   U.S. Stocks
   Commodities
   Bonds & Rates
   Currencies Market Data
   Mutual Funds & ETFs
 * Opinion
   Columnists
   Gerard Baker
   Sadanand Dhume
   Allysia Finley
   James Freeman
   William A. Galston
   Daniel Henninger
   Holman W. Jenkins
   Andy Kessler
   William McGurn
   Walter Russell Mead
   Peggy Noonan
   Mary Anastasia O'Grady
   Jason Riley
   Joseph Sternberg
   Kimberley A. Strassel
   More
   Editorials
   Commentary
   Future View
   Houses of Worship
   Cross Country
   Letters to the Editor
   The Weekend Interview
   Potomac Watch Podcast
   Foreign Edition Podcast
   Free Expression Podcast
   Opinion Video
   Notable & Quotable
 * Arts & Culture
   Topics
   Books
   Film
   Fine Art
   Food & Cooking
   History
   Music
   Television
   Theater
   Reviews
   Film Reviews
   Television Reviews
   Theater Reviews
   Masterpiece Series
   Music Reviews
   Dance Reviews
   Opera Reviews
   Exhibition Reviews
   Cultural Commentary
   More
   WSJ Puzzles
   What To Watch
   Arts Calendar
 * Lifestyle
   Topics
   Careers
   Cars
   Fitness
   Relationships
   Travel
   Workplace
   More
   On Wine
   Work & Life
   Carry On
   On The Clock
   Elizabeth Bernstein
   Turning Points
   WSJ Puzzles
   Recipes
 * Real Estate
   Topics
   Commercial Real Estate
   Luxury Homes
 * Personal Finance
   Topics
   Retirement
   Savings
   Credit
   Taxes
   Mortgages
   More
   Jason Zweig
   Laura Saunders
   James Mackintosh
 * Health
   Topics
   Healthcare
   Pharma
   Wellness
   More
   Your Health
 * Science
   Topics
   Archaeology
   Biology
   Environment
   Physics
   Space & Astronomy
   More
   The Future of Everything
 * Style
   Topics
   Beauty
   Design
   Fashion
   More
   Off Brand
   On Trend
   My Monday Morning
 * Sports
   Topics
   Baseball
   Basketball
   Football
   Golf
   Hockey
   Olympics
   Soccer
   Tennis
   More
   Jason Gay



Truck Drivers Bear Big Burden on Data Collection. Some Companies Want to Change
That.

Share
Resize
8

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------



Listen

(2 min)






This copy is for your personal, non-commercial use only. Distribution and use of
this material are governed by our Subscriber Agreement and by copyright law. For
non-personal use or to order multiple copies, please contact Dow Jones Reprints
at 1-800-843-0008 or visit www.djreprints.com.

https://www.wsj.com/articles/truck-drivers-bear-big-burden-on-data-collection-some-companies-want-to-change-that-37fe8324

 1. CIO Journal


TRUCK DRIVERS BEAR BIG BURDEN ON DATA COLLECTION. SOME COMPANIES WANT TO CHANGE
THAT.


ESTES EXPRESS LINES IS LOOKING TO AUTOMATE MORE DATA COLLECTION AND STREAMLINE
DATA SHARING TO REDUCE THE BURDEN ON TRUCKERS AND DOCKWORKERS TO TRACK GOODS

By

Isabelle Bousquette


April 26, 2023 9:00 am ET

Share
Resize
8

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------



Listen

(2 min)



Former truck driver Darren Suarez is terminal manager at Estes Express Lines’
Pine Brook loading dock in New Jersey. Photo: Isabelle Bousquette

Being a truck driver in the 1980s was terrible. Just ask former driver Darren
Suarez, who spent years perched in boiling hot cabs with no air conditioning and
only crank-down windows. But it wasn’t just the discomfort: The paperwork was
voluminous. Mr. Suarez recalls how he would have to write down information about
shipment sizes and pickup times at red lights, scribbling so quickly that his
notes were often unreadable even to himself.

Truck cabs today typically have air conditioning, and a lot else has changed
since then, but one thing hasn’t: Drivers are still tasked with collecting and
keeping track of detailed shipment data for logistics companies. And although
that process has transitioned from paper to digital via app, drivers still bear
the brunt of that burden—and it is one of the modern supply chain’s major
inefficiencies. 

“Every time I go out on a terminal visit, I will have at least one driver or one
dockworker look at me and refer to themselves as having sausage fingers,” said
Estes Express Lines Chief Information Officer Todd Florence. “They didn’t sign
on to want to be a data-entry clerk. It’s frustrating for them.”

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Newsletter Sign-up

WSJ | CIO Journal

The Morning Download delivers daily insights and news on business technology
from the CIO Journal team.

Preview

Subscribe

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Now the trucking industry’s digital evolution may be at a tipping point, driven
by the rise in e-commerce, the supply-chain challenges laid bare during the
pandemic and customer demand for more real-time tracking, among other forces.
Some CIOs are looking to reduce the amount of tedious and repetitive data
collection drivers are doing by better integrating data from other company
systems, tapping better software and investing in automated data-collecting
devices like cameras and sensors. The upshot, Mr. Florence said, could be more
accurate and more real-time data.

For Richmond, Va.-based Estes and other trucking companies, real-time data is
increasingly vital to optimizing operations and planning pickups, deliveries and
driver assignments most efficiently—as well as providing greater visibility to
customers. 

“Frankly it just comes down to: If you don’t have the data, you’re not going to
get the customer,” said Avery Vise, a vice president at freight research firm
FTR Transportation Intelligence. 

Still, the system at many companies is far from optimal. In most cases, drivers
and dockworkers are typing in information, taking pictures and scanning bar
codes throughout a package’s life cycle, said Mr. Florence. Sometimes they are
inputting the same information over and over in multiple formats—and the data
may already exist in other company systems, Mr. Florence said. The process is
prone to errors and frustrating for employees, added the CIO, whose company is
the largest privately held freight transportation company in North America.

Here are some of the ways Estes, which employs more than 10,000 drivers and
makes roughly 50,000 deliveries a day, is working to automate its system and
solve tracking problems:


STREAMLINE DATA SHARING

Estes Express Lines truck driver Juan Gonzalez shows the app used for keeping
track of detailed shipment data. Photo: Isabelle Bousquette

Breaking down silos between data in different company systems could be one
solution, Mr. Florence said. If all the information about a given piece of
freight—including information collected by drivers, tracked by office workers
and sent in directly from customers—flowed into one single location, there would
be less need to collect data that the company may already have elsewhere.

To make that a reality, Mr. Florence said he has built a digital twin, which
acts as a virtual representation of each piece of freight passing through the
network, and can function as that single location. The platform was built
leveraging data-management platform Denodo as the foundation, he said.

Building out the platform meant that, for example, when a customer inputs
information about freight, the driver won’t separately have to upload all the
same information when picking it up. So far the company said it has internal
savings of about 10% in infrastructure and labor costs by eliminating the need
to duplicate or store data across multiple platforms. It is continuing to scale
out the platform across the company.

Advertisement - Scroll to Continue




DIGITIZE DATA FASTER

Better software also could help lighten the burden, Mr. Florence said.

Typically when freight is picked up, the customer provides a bill of lading,
which contains the complete address of the shipper and consignee, number of
pieces, description, weight and other key information. It is still industry
standard for this bill to be a physical piece of paper, said Evan Armstrong,
president of Armstrong & Associates Inc., a logistics-industry research group.

Mr. Florence said the company is now working to roll out a system where drivers
would be able to just take a photo of the bill and upload it—rather than typing
in each piece of information into the app. As the system rolls out, back-end
employees are looking at the photo and doing the manual data input themselves,
Mr. Florence said.




SUPPLY CHAINS HAVE CHANGED FOREVER

Nearshoring. Automation. Supplier diversification. Sustainability. Here’s how
companies are reshaping their logistics.

Here’s How Supply Chains Are Being Reshaped for a New Era of Global Trade
The Shift to Nearshoring Brings Production Hurdles Closer to Home
SEC's Climate-Disclosure Rule Isn’t Here, but It May as Well Be, Many Businesses
Say
Truck Drivers Bear Big Burden on Data Collection. Some Companies Want to Change
That.
A Cyberattack Forced a Logistics Company to Temporarily Halt Operations
CFOs Focus on Building Resilient Supply Chains, Even as Pandemic Disruptions
Fade
Investors Continue to Back Logistics Tech
Private Investors Looking to Capitalize on Nearshoring Trends Turn to Mexico

But the ultimate goal is to leverage optical character recognition, or OCR,
technology and artificial intelligence to automate that process.

Using OCR and AI on the bill of lading would be much more challenging than on
standardized forms, such as checks, since each customer can format its bill of
lading in its own unique way as there is no clear industry standard, Mr.
Florence said.

“So we want to get to a point where we’re extracting that data out of the image
for those customers so that my driver doesn’t have to enter it in,” said Mr.
Florence.

Automate data collection

Mr. Florence also is looking for more automated ways to collect data, such as
cameras and sensors. For example, in the Estes Pine Brook loading dock in New
Jersey, there are ground sensors that automatically collect information on tire
pressure as tires run over them—a task that was previously manual, performed
with tire pressure gauges or other instruments.

“We used to kick them,” said Mr. Suarez, who is now retired from driving and
works as the terminal manager at Estes’s Pine Brook loading dock.

SHARE YOUR THOUGHTS

Who does your company rely on to collect data, and could those processes be more
efficient? Join the conversation below.

GPS and telematics data, mounted cameras and other devices on trailers also have
provided information that drivers used to have to manually keep track of,
including hours of work and locations, said Kyle Perillo, operations manager at
Estes.

According to Mr. Vise, companies have the opportunity to leverage devices like
sensors more than they already do to automate more data collection. For example,
he said, at the moment, drivers typically need to signal when they have made a
delivery, but using cameras or sensors could allow for automatic signals about
the movement of that freight. However, Mr. Vise said he doesn’t know of any
companies doing that, and scaled-out deployment of such solutions are likely
further in the future.

Despite challenges, the transformation at Estes is ongoing, according to Mr.
Florence. He also said he expects a big payoff given the tens of thousands of
deliveries a day. “If I only save my city driver two minutes per pickup a
day…that’s a lot of time. And that’s a lot of dollars.”

Write to Isabelle Bousquette at isabelle.bousquette@wsj.com

Copyright ©2023 Dow Jones & Company, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
87990cbe856818d5eddac44c7b1cdeb8

Appeared in the April 27, 2023, print edition as 'Truck Drivers Bear
Data-Collection Burden'.

Show Conversation (8)


WHAT TO READ NEXT


Sponsored Offers
 * AT&T:
   Extra $50 off with this AT&T secret promo code
 * Walmart:
   $20 off when you sign up for Walmart Plus
 * Best Buy:
   Deal of the Day Best Buy coupon: Score up to 50% off
 * eBay:
   +30% Off today with this eBay coupon*
 * Groupon:
   Members: Extra 15% Off - Valid Sitewide!
 * Samsung:
   Samsung promo code for up to 40% Off + Free shipping


WHY YOUR COMPANY MAY NEED A NEW NET-ZERO STRATEGY—AND A PLAYBOOK FOR IT

Company leaders can deploy a three-step, systems-focused climate strategy to
help multiply climate impact and business opportunities in the shift to a
climate-aligned economy


ARE YOU READY TO ‘MESH’ YOUR DATA?

By breaking down monolithic architectures into modular domains and strategically
embedding specialized data talent, a data mesh can help address growing demand
for data access across the organization.


HPE CTO: ‘LEAN INTO AI—WITH GUARDRAILS’

A company-level AI oversight board is helping Hewlett Packard Enterprise when it
comes to using data, says CTO Fidelma Russo
Content from our Sponsor: Deloitte
The Wall Street Journal news department was not involved in the creation of this
content.



MOST POPULAR NEWS

 * THE U.S. COLLEGES OFFERING THE BEST VALUE
   
   

 * WRECK OF MISSING F-35 JET FIGHTER FOUND IN SOUTH CAROLINA
   
   

 * THE FED ISN’T GETTING THE ECONOMY IT EXPECTED
   
   

 * OKTOBERFEST NOW HAS ITS CULTURE WAR. IT ISN’T ABOUT THE BEER.
   
   

 * COACH PRIME CONQUERED COLLEGE FOOTBALL. NOW COMES THE HARD PART.
   
   

MOST POPULAR OPINION

 * OPINION: WHY KEN PAXTON WAS ACQUITTED
   
   

 * OPINION: BIDEN, TRUMP AND COGNITIVE TESTING
   
   

 * OPINION: DAYQUIL, COVID VACCINE BOOSTERS AND FDA SCIENCE
   
   

 * OPINION: INFLATION WILL CONTINUE UNTIL MORALE IMPROVES
   
   

 * OPINION: GARY GENSLER TELLS A CLIMATE WHOPPER
   
   

MOST POPULAR OPINION

 * WHY KEN PAXTON WAS ACQUITTED
   
   

 * BIDEN, TRUMP AND COGNITIVE TESTING
   
   

 * DAYQUIL, COVID VACCINE BOOSTERS AND FDA SCIENCE
   
   

 * INFLATION WILL CONTINUE UNTIL MORALE IMPROVES
   
   

 * GARY GENSLER TELLS A CLIMATE WHOPPER
   
   

RECOMMENDED VIDEOS







 * The Wall Street Journal
 * English Edition
   
   EditionEnglish中文 (Chinese)日本語 (Japanese)
   
 * Subscribe NowSign In
 * Back to Top «

WSJ Membership

 * Buy Side Exclusives
 * Subscription Options
 * Why Subscribe?
 * Corporate Subscriptions
 * WSJ Higher Education Program
 * WSJ High School Program
 * Public Library Program
 * WSJ Live
 * Commercial Partnerships

Customer Service

 * Customer Center
 * Contact Us
 * Cancel My Subscription

Tools & Features

 * Newsletters & Alerts
 * Guides
 * Topics
 * My News
 * RSS Feeds
 * Video Center
 * Watchlist
 * Podcasts
 * Visual Stories

Ads

 * Advertise
 * Commercial Real Estate Ads
 * Place a Classified Ad
 * Sell Your Business
 * Sell Your Home
 * Recruitment & Career Ads
 * Coupons
 * Digital Self Service

More

 * About Us
 * Content Partnerships
 * Corrections
 * Jobs at WSJ
 * News Archive
 * Register for Free
 * Reprints & Licensing
 * Buy Issues
 * WSJ Shop

 * WSJ Membership Benefits
 * Customer Center
 * Cancel My Subscription
 * Legal Policies
 * Manage Cookies

 * Facebook
 * Twitter
 * Instagram
 * YouTube
 * Podcasts
 * Snapchat
 * Google Play
 * App Store

Dow Jones Products

 * Barron's
 * BigCharts
 * Dow Jones Newswires
 * Factiva
 * Financial News
 * Mansion Global
 * MarketWatch
 * Risk & Compliance
 * Buy Side from WSJ
 * WSJ Pro
 * WSJ Video
 * WSJ Wine

 * Privacy Notice
 * Cookie Notice
 * Manage Cookies
 * Copyright Policy
 * Data Policy
 * Subscriber Agreement & Terms of Use
 * Your Ad Choices
 * Accessibility
 * Copyright ©2023 Dow Jones & Company, Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Back to Top «
English Edition

EditionEnglish中文 (Chinese)日本語 (Japanese)


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

 * Facebook
 * Twitter
 * Instagram
 * YouTube
 * Podcasts
 * Snapchat

WSJ Membership

 * Buy Side Exclusives
 * Subscription Options
 * Why Subscribe?
 * Corporate Subscriptions
 * WSJ Higher Education Program
 * WSJ High School Program
 * Public Library Program
 * WSJ Live
 * Commercial Partnerships

Customer Service

 * Customer Center
 * Contact Us
 * Cancel My Subscription

Tools & Features

 * Newsletters & Alerts
 * Guides
 * Topics
 * My News
 * RSS Feeds
 * Video Center
 * Watchlist
 * Podcasts
 * Visual Stories

Ads

 * Advertise
 * Commercial Real Estate Ads
 * Place a Classified Ad
 * Sell Your Business
 * Sell Your Home
 * Recruitment & Career Ads
 * Coupons
 * Digital Self Service

More

 * About Us
 * Content Partnerships
 * Corrections
 * Jobs at WSJ
 * News Archive
 * Register for Free
 * Reprints & Licensing
 * Buy Issues
 * WSJ Shop

 * WSJ Membership Benefits
 * Customer Center
 * Cancel My Subscription
 * Legal Policies
 * Manage Cookies

 * Google Play
 * App Store

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Sign In
Copyright ©2023 Dow Jones & Company, Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Copyright ©2023 Dow Jones & Company, Inc. All Rights Reserved

This copy is for your personal, non-commercial use only. Distribution and use of
this material are governed by our Subscriber Agreement and by copyright law. For
non-personal use or to order multiple copies, please contact Dow Jones Reprints
at 1-800-843-0008 or visit www.djreprints.com.


INTRO OFFER

€2 per month

Subscribe Now