www.reuters.com Open in urlscan Pro
2600:9000:211c:f600:15:5a3e:9d40:93a1  Public Scan

URL: https://www.reuters.com/legal/ny-top-court-rejects-church-challenge-abortion-coverage-law-2024-05-21/
Submission: On May 27 via manual from US — Scanned from US

Form analysis 0 forms found in the DOM

Text Content

Skip to main content

Exclusive news, data and analytics for financial market professionalsLearn more
aboutRefinitiv

Reuters home
 * WorldChevron
   Browse World
    * Africa
    * Americas
    * Asia Pacific
    * China
    * Europe
    * India
    * Israel and Hamas at War
   
    * Japan
    * Middle East
    * Ukraine and Russia at War
    * United Kingdom
    * United States
    * US Elections
    * Reuters Next
   
   Latest in World
    * Ukraine launches missile attack on Luhansk, Russia-installed governor says
      
      A Ukrainian missile attack triggered a fire on Monday in the Russian-held
      northeastern city of Luhansk, the latest in a series of strikes near the
      city, the regional Russia-installed governor said.
      
      9 min ago
    * Azerbaijan may borrow $5 bln for major infrastructure projects, finance
      minister says
      
      Azerbaijan wants to borrow $5 billion from international credit
      institutions in the coming years for large infrastructure projects,
      including in territories secured in a lightning military offensive in
      September, the finance minister told Reuters.
      
      13 min ago
    * Pope used vulgar Italian word to refer to LGBT people, Italian newspapers
      report
      18 min ago
      
    * North Korea says its latest satellite launch exploded in flight
      
      North Korea said its attempt to launch a new military reconnaissance
      satellite ended in failure on Monday when a newly developed rocket engine
      exploded in flight.
      
      26 min ago

 * BusinessChevron
   Browse Business
    * Aerospace & Defense
    * Autos & Transportation
    * Davos
    * Energy
    * Environment
    * Finance
    * Healthcare & Pharmaceuticals
   
    * Media & Telecom
    * Retail & Consumer
    * Future of Health
    * Future of Money
    * Take Five
    * World at Work
   
   Latest in Business
    * Stellantis to introduce Italy-made hybrid versions of Fiat 500 EV, Jeep
      Compass
      13 min ago
      
    * Aeromexico temporarily suspends Mexico City-Quito route
      26 min ago
      
    * Exclusive: Nokia to supply 5G radio equipment to Portugal's MEO, sources
      say
      34 min ago
      
    * Italy's Benetton plans restructuring as losses mount, sources say
      37 min ago
      article with gallery

 * MarketsChevron
   Browse Markets
    * Asian Markets
    * Carbon Markets
    * Commodities
    * Currencies
    * Deals
    * Emerging Markets
    * ETFs
    * European Markets
   
    * Funds
    * Global Market Data
    * Rates & Bonds
    * Stocks
    * U.S. Markets
    * Wealth
    * Macro Matters
   
   Latest in Markets
    * Canada, Mexico, Argentina halve trade settlement to one day
      
      Canada, Mexico and Argentina on Monday started to settle securities trades
      faster, halving settlement time to one day, in a move designed to reduce
      counterparty risk and improve market liquidity.
      
      23 min ago
    * TSX buoyed by gains in commodity stocks as inflation data looms
      35 min ago
      
    * Argentina markets keep wary eye on Milei reform bill hold-ups
      
      Argentina's markets have a wary eye on President Javier Milei's sprawling
      reform bill that is grinding through Congress and facing likely amendments
      in the Senate that will push it back to the lower house and gum up its
      final approval.
      
      an hour ago
    * Brazil inflation expectations to improve over time, says central bank
      chief
      8:26 AM HST
      

 * SustainabilityChevron
   Browse Sustainability
    * Boards, Policy & Regulation
    * Climate & Energy
    * Land Use & Biodiversity
    * Society & Equity
    * Sustainable Finance & Reporting
    * The Switch
    * Reuters Impact
   
   Latest in Sustainability
    * Solaria sees higher energy prices later this year, shares rise
      
      Spanish solar panel maker Solaria said on Monday it expected energy prices
      to recover over the year, which would help the firm reach its 2024
      profitability target.
      
      14 min ago
    * Caribbean leader blasts 'empty' climate promises at small islands summit
      8:35 AM HST
      
    * Meta adds safety features to CrowdTangle in bid to address EU concerns
      8:17 AM HST
      
    * Italy's solar power capacity rises to 32 GW, large projects jump in Q1
      6:00 AM HST
      

 * LegalChevron
   Browse Legal
    * Government
    * Legal Industry
    * Litigation
    * Transactional
    * US Supreme Court
   
   Latest in Legal
    * Israel concerned over possible ICC arrest warrants related to Gaza war
      26 min ago
      
    * Judge denies Alec Baldwin request to drop indictment for 'Rust' shooting
      May 24, 2024
      article with video
    * Prosecutors ask judge to bar Trump from comments endangering law
      enforcement
      May 24, 2024
      
    * Louisiana becomes first US state to classify abortion pills as controlled
      substances
      May 24, 2024
      article with gallery

 * BreakingviewsChevron
   Browse Breakingviews
    * Breakingviews Predictions
   
   Latest in Breakingviews
    * ESR buyout showcases depths of Hong Kong misery
      May 26, 2024
      
    * Breakingviews: Live Nation breakup will leave Swifties unsated
      May 24, 2024
      
    * Macron’s Draghi sales pitch is a long shot
      May 24, 2024
      
    * Japan’s new widowmaker trade may have shorter life
      May 24, 2024
      

 * TechnologyChevron
   Browse Technology
    * Cybersecurity
    * Space
    * Disrupted
    * Reuters Momentum
   
   Latest in Technology
    * Exclusive: Nokia to supply 5G radio equipment to Portugal's MEO, sources
      say
      34 min ago
      
    * Meta adds safety features to CrowdTangle in bid to address EU concerns
      8:17 AM HST
      
    * Exclusive: Amazon in talks with Italy to invest billions of euros in cloud
      plan, sources say
      6:22 AM HST
      
    * EU clears law to increase domestic green tech production
      5:04 AM HST
      

 * Investigations
 * MoreChevron
   Sports
    * Olympics
    * Athletics
    * Baseball
    * Basketball
    * Cricket
    * Cycling
    * Formula 1
    * Golf
    * NFL
    * NHL
    * Soccer
    * Tennis
   
   Science
   Lifestyle
   Graphics
   Pictures
   Podcasts
   Fact Check
   Video
   Sponsored Content
    * Reuters Plus
    * Coupons
   
   Trending Stories
    * Worldcategory
      Israeli attack on Rafah tent camp kills 45, prompts international outcry
      article with gallery
    * Worldcategory
      Pakistan temperatures cross 52 C in heatwave
      
    * Worldcategory
      Papua New Guinea landslide buried more than 2,000 people, government says
      article with video
    * Worldcategory
      Egyptian guard killed in shooting on Rafah border, Israel and Egypt
      investigating
      
      A member of Egypt's security forces was killed in a shooting incident near
      the Rafah border crossing between Egypt and the Gaza Strip and an
      investigation is under way, Egypt's military spokesperson said in a
      statement on Monday.

My ViewMy ViewChevron
Search
Sign InRegister
Menu
 * My ViewMy View
 * FollowingFollowing
 * SavedSaved

 * Litigation
 * GovernmentChevron
 * Human RightsChevron
 * HealthChevron
 * Civil RightsChevron


NY TOP COURT REJECTS CHURCH CHALLENGE TO ABORTION COVERAGE LAW

By Brendan Pierson
May 22, 20245:28 AM HSTUpdated 5 days ago
Save
Text
 * Small Text
 * Medium Text
 * Large Text

Share
 * Twitter
 * Facebook
 * Linkedin
 * Email
 * Link

A view of the New York State Court of Appeals building is seen in Albany, New
York October 12, 2011. REUTERS/Hans Pennink/ File Photo Purchase Licensing
RightsNew Tab, opens new tab
May 21 (Reuters) - New York's highest court on Tuesday ruled that employers'
health insurance plans have to cover medically necessary abortions, rejecting a
lawsuit by the Roman Catholic Diocese of Albany claiming that the law's
exemption for religious employers was too narrow.
The New York Court of Appeals found that the rule, passed in 2017 by the state's
Department of Financial Services (DFS), did not violate religious employers'
freedom because both the rule and its religious exemption were neutral and
generally applicable to all employers.
Advertisement · Scroll to continue

The 2017 rule was made into law by the state legislature in 2022, though the law
was not challenged in the lawsuit.
"We continue to believe that the regulatory action by the state, as well as
subsequent legislative action, requiring religious organizations to provide and
pay for coverage of abortion in its employee health plans is unconstitutional
and unjust," Dennis Poust, executive director of the New York State Catholic
Conference, said in a statement. He said the Diocese would appeal to the U.S.
Supreme Court.
Advertisement · Scroll to continue

"DFS's actions have ensured that women in New York have control over their
reproductive choices, and that insurers cover abortions and contraceptives with
no copayments, deductibles or any out-of-pocket costs," DFS Superintendent
Adrienne Harris said in a statement.
The religious exemption in the rule applies to non-profit entities whose primary
purpose is the "inculcation of religious values" and that primarily employ and
serve people who share its religious beliefs.

The Diocese alleged that this exemption was too narrow because it would not
include religious organizations with a broader purpose than inculcating
religious values, such as serving the poor, or that employed or served a large
number of people who did not share their religion.
The Court of Appeals previously rejected the diocese's challenge in 2020, citing
an earlier case upholding a contraception coverage requirement with a similar
religious exemption.

In June 2021, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that Philadelphia could not refuse to
place foster children with a Catholic agency that turned away same-sex couples
as would-be foster parents. It then ordered the New York court to reconsider the
abortion coverage case in light of that ruling.
The court said in Tuesday's decision that the Supreme Court's ruling did not
change the outcome because it was narrowly focused on the facts of that case,
and did not overturn the longstanding precedent that neutral, generally
applicable laws can sometimes restrict religious expression.

Republican-led states have banned or restricted abortion in the wake of the
Supreme Court's 2022 ruling eliminating a nationwide right to abortion.
Democratic states have moved to safeguard and expand abortion access.

Jumpstart your morning with the latest legal news delivered straight to your
inbox from The Daily Docket newsletter. Sign up here.

Reporting By Brendan Pierson in New York, Editing by Alexia Garamfalvi and David
Gregorio

Our Standards: The Thomson Reuters Trust Principles.New Tab, opens new tab

Save
Share
 * Twitter
 * Facebook
 * Linkedin
 * Email
 * Link

Purchase Licensing Rights
Brendan Pierson

Thomson Reuters

Brendan Pierson reports on product liability litigation and on all areas of
health care law. He can be reached at brendan.pierson@thomsonreuters.com.

 * Email
 * Twitter


READ NEXT / EDITOR'S PICKS

ChevronChevron
 * LitigationcategoryFamilies of Uvalde school shooting victims sue Meta,
   Microsoft, gunmaker
 * TechnologycategoryOpenAI, Microsoft defeat US consumer-privacy lawsuit for
   now
 * article with gallery
   BusinesscategoryLive Nation ticket buyers sue in wake of US Justice
   Department case
 * COVID-19categoryMayo Clinic must face religious bias claims over COVID
   vaccine policy, court rules
 * EnvironmentcategoryCase over frozen-to-death Ohio woman should be heard by
   utility regulators, court holds
 * DiversitycategoryCBS says First Amendment bars white screenwriter's bias
   lawsuit
 * WorldcategoryIsrael concerned over possible ICC arrest warrants related to
   Gaza war
 * article with video
   LegalcategoryJudge denies Alec Baldwin request to drop indictment for 'Rust'
   shooting
 * article with gallery
   WorldcategoryLouisiana becomes first US state to classify abortion pills as
   controlled substances
 * GovernmentcategoryGroups fight California attorney general's document demands
   in plastics pollution probe
 * TechnologycategoryMeta submits changes to UK privacy compliance proposals,
   CMA says
 * article with gallery
   TechnologycategoryEU data protection board says ChatGPT still not meeting
   data accuracy standards
 * White Collar CrimecategoryExiled Chinese businessman stole $1 billion to fund
   luxury lifestyle, prosecutor says
 * BusinesscategoryEmcure, HDT settle legal fight over COVID vaccine technology
 * Employee Benefits & Executive CompensationcategoryNLRB ruling that expanded
   money damages for workers rejected by 5th Circuit
 * BankruptcycategoryRite Aid nears deal on post-bankruptcy financing




INDUSTRY INSIGHTCHEVRON

 * LegalLawyer fired from law firm Husch Blackwell admits to tax crimes
   
   David Thomas
   
   May 22, 2024
 * LegalHarvard hires law firm King & Spalding amid US House probe
   
   Mike Scarcella, David Thomas
   
   January 24, 2024
 * LegalAttorneys with disabilities are rare at law firms. It doesn't have to be
   that way, group says.
   
   Karen Sloan
   
   December 5, 2023
 * Industry InsightCompanies need to integrate climate reporting across
   functions to comply with California’s new law
   
   Henry Engler
   
   October 20, 2023




SITE INDEX


LATEST

 * Home
 * Authors
 * Topic sitemap


BROWSE

 * World
 * Business
 * Markets
 * Sustainability
 * Legal
 * Breakingviews
 * Technology
 * InvestigationsNew Tab, opens new tab
 * Sports
 * Science
 * Lifestyle


MEDIA

 * 
   VideosNew Tab, opens new tab
 * 
   Pictures
 * 
   GraphicsNew Tab, opens new tab


ABOUT REUTERS

 * About ReutersNew Tab, opens new tab
 * CareersNew Tab, opens new tab
 * Reuters News AgencyNew Tab, opens new tab
 * Brand Attribution GuidelinesNew Tab, opens new tab
 * Reuters LeadershipNew Tab, opens new tab
 * Reuters Fact CheckNew Tab, opens new tab
 * Reuters Diversity ReportNew Tab, opens new tab


STAY INFORMED

 * Download the App (iOS)New Tab, opens new tab
 * Download the App (Android)New Tab, opens new tab
 * NewslettersNew Tab, opens new tab


INFORMATION YOU CAN TRUST

Reuters, the news and media division of Thomson Reuters, is the world’s largest
multimedia news provider, reaching billions of people worldwide every day.
Reuters provides business, financial, national and international news to
professionals via desktop terminals, the world's media organizations, industry
events and directly to consumers.


FOLLOW US

 * Twitter
 * Facebook
 * Instagram
 * Youtube
 * Linkedin


THOMSON REUTERS PRODUCTS

 * WESTLAWNEW TAB, OPENS NEW TAB
   
   BUILD THE STRONGEST ARGUMENT RELYING ON AUTHORITATIVE CONTENT,
   ATTORNEY-EDITOR EXPERTISE, AND INDUSTRY DEFINING TECHNOLOGY.

 * ONESOURCENEW TAB, OPENS NEW TAB
   
   THE MOST COMPREHENSIVE SOLUTION TO MANAGE ALL YOUR COMPLEX AND EVER-EXPANDING
   TAX AND COMPLIANCE NEEDS.

 * CHECKPOINTNEW TAB, OPENS NEW TAB
   
   THE INDUSTRY LEADER FOR ONLINE INFORMATION FOR TAX, ACCOUNTING AND FINANCE
   PROFESSIONALS.


LSEG PRODUCTS

 * WORKSPACENEW TAB, OPENS NEW TAB
   
   ACCESS UNMATCHED FINANCIAL DATA, NEWS AND CONTENT IN A HIGHLY-CUSTOMISED
   WORKFLOW EXPERIENCE ON DESKTOP, WEB AND MOBILE.

 * DATA CATALOGUENEW TAB, OPENS NEW TAB
   
   BROWSE AN UNRIVALLED PORTFOLIO OF REAL-TIME AND HISTORICAL MARKET DATA AND
   INSIGHTS FROM WORLDWIDE SOURCES AND EXPERTS.

 * WORLD-CHECKNEW TAB, OPENS NEW TAB
   
   SCREEN FOR HEIGHTENED RISK INDIVIDUAL AND ENTITIES GLOBALLY TO HELP UNCOVER
   HIDDEN RISKS IN BUSINESS RELATIONSHIPS AND HUMAN NETWORKS.

 * Advertise With UsNew Tab, opens new tab
 * Advertising GuidelinesNew Tab, opens new tab
 * CouponsNew Tab, opens new tab
 * Purchase Licensing RightsNew Tab, opens new tab

 * CookiesNew Tab, opens new tab
 * Terms of UseNew Tab, opens new tab
 * PrivacyNew Tab, opens new tab
 * Digital AccessibilityNew Tab, opens new tab
 * CorrectionsNew Tab, opens new tab
 * Site FeedbackNew Tab, opens new tab

All quotes delayed a minimum of 15 minutes. See here for a complete list of
exchanges and delays.

© 2024 Reuters. All rights reserved