www.npr.org Open in urlscan Pro
23.205.107.85  Public Scan

Form analysis
0 forms found in the DOM

Text Content

Accessibility links
 * Skip to main content
 * Keyboard shortcuts for audio player

Play Live Radio
 * Hourly News
 * Listen Live
 * Playlist

 * Open Navigation Menu
 * 
 * 
 * Newsletters
 * Sign In
 * NPR Shop
 * Donate

Close Navigation Menu
 * Home
 * News Expand/collapse submenu for News
   * National
   * World
   * Politics
   * Business
   * Health
   * Science
   * Climate
   * Race
 * Culture Expand/collapse submenu for Culture
   * Books
   * Movies
   * Television
   * Pop Culture
   * Food
   * Art & Design
   * Performing Arts
   * Life Kit
   * Gaming
 * Music Expand/collapse submenu for Music
   * Tiny Desk
   * Hip-Hop 50
   * All Songs Considered
   * Music Features
   * Live Sessions
 * Podcasts & Shows Expand/collapse submenu for Podcasts & Shows
   Daily
    * Morning Edition
    * Weekend Edition Saturday
    * Weekend Edition Sunday
    * All Things Considered
    * Fresh Air
    * Up First
   
   Featured
    * The NPR Politics Podcast
    * Throughline
    * Trump's Trials
    * Pop Culture Happy Hour
   
    * More Podcasts & Shows

 * Search
 * Newsletters
 * Sign In
 * NPR Shop

 * 
 * Tiny Desk
 * Hip-Hop 50
 * All Songs Considered
 * Music Features
 * Live Sessions

 * About NPR
 * Diversity
 * Organization
 * NPR Network
 * Support
 * Careers
 * Connect
 * Press
 * Ethics

How states giving rights to fetuses could set up a national case on abortion
Fetal personhood made headlines recently when the Alabama Supreme Court ruled
that embryos are "extrauterine children." The ruling raised questions across the
country about fetal personhood.


LAW


HOW STATES GIVING RIGHTS TO FETUSES COULD SET UP A NATIONAL CASE ON ABORTION

March 5, 20244:29 PM ET

By 

Regan McCarthy

HOW STATES GIVING RIGHTS TO FETUSES COULD SET UP A NATIONAL CASE ON ABORTION

Listen· 4:294-Minute ListenPlaylist
Toggle more options
 * Download
 * Embed
   Embed <iframe src="https://www.npr.org/player/embed/1235970171/1236021856"
   width="100%" height="290" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" title="NPR embedded
   audio player">

Enlarge this image

Abortion access advocates are chanting and waiving signs outside the Florida
Supreme Court. Inside, justices have just heard arguments on the ballot language
for a proposed state constitutional amendment that would protect abortion access
up to the point of viability. Regan McCarthy hide caption

toggle caption
Regan McCarthy


Abortion access advocates are chanting and waiving signs outside the Florida
Supreme Court. Inside, justices have just heard arguments on the ballot language
for a proposed state constitutional amendment that would protect abortion access
up to the point of viability.

Regan McCarthy

TALLAHASSEE, Fla. — Last month, when the Florida Supreme Court heard arguments
for a proposed state constitutional amendment that would explicitly protect
access to abortion, the discussion took a surprising turn for attendees like
state House Minority Leader Fentrice Driskell.

"The chief justice seemed to really be trained on trying to understand what the
effects of this ballot initiative would be on other areas of the law," Driskell
said.

Specifically, Chief Justice Carlos Muñiz wanted to know how the amendment might
interact with Article I of Florida's Constitution, which grants "all natural
persons" the inalienable right to life.

Sponsor Message



"I don't know that I could affirmatively say that the term 'natural person'
doesn't, as a matter of ordinary meaning, include the unborn," Muñiz said during
the hearing.

It wasn't the first time Muñiz made that type of comment. He previously spoke
about how Article I relates to rights for fetuses during a hearing on Florida's
current 15-week abortion ban.

"Chief Justice Muñiz is all but writing up an engraved invitation to make this
argument to the Florida Supreme Court," said University of California-Davis law
professor Mary Ziegler.

The court's ruling in both cases is pending and it remains to be seen whether
the chief justice's questions about fetal personhood will impact the outcomes.
But Ziegler said the question of fetal personhood "isn't going anywhere."

It's a topic that's made headlines since the Alabama Supreme Court ruled in a
recent wrongful death case that embryos are "extrauterine children." That ruling
raised questions around access to in-vitro fertilization (IVF) in the state and
sent ripples throughout the country.

Since then, Alabama lawmakers have rushed to support a bill to protect IVF, a
fertility procedure that remains very popular with Republicans and Democrats
alike. In Florida, lawmakers paused their efforts to add fetuses to their own
state's wrongful death law.



Ziegler, who has written several books on abortion law and history, said many of
the steps states are taking on the issue are part of a plan that's been in place
since the 1960s.


STATE LAWS GIVING RIGHTS TO FETUSES MAY BE SETTING THE PIECES FOR A LONGER GAME

For decades, members of the anti-abortion rights movement have been working to
put laws on the books across the country that extend rights to fetuses — like
fetal homicide, wrongful death, and child support during pregnancy.

"The idea was to go to sympathetic judges, like those on the Florida Supreme
Court," Ziegler told NPR, "and say, 'Isn't it weird that a fetus isn't a rights
holder for the purposes of the state constitution or the purposes of the
abortion law, but it is in all these other contexts?'"

Ziegler said each new law passed creates a cumulative effect. The more times a
state recognizes a fetus as a person in one area of law, the easier it will be
for lawyers to make the argument that it's inconsistent that fetuses aren't
recognized as people by the Constitution. If states like Alabama and Florida
recognize fetuses as people in their laws and constitutions, she said, it helps
set the dominos for an argument on the national level.

"The more states pass laws recognizing a fetus as a rights holder in a variety
of contexts, the more you're going to see the anti-abortion movement wanting to
return to the U.S. Supreme Court and say, 'Actually under the 14th Amendment of
the federal Constitution, a fetus is also a rights holder,'" Ziegler said.

When the U.S. Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade in 2022, decisions about
abortion regulation reverted to individual states. But Ziegler said if states
can continually make laws that give rights to fetuses and that makes it to the
highest court, it could potentially cut off access to abortion nationwide.



Ziegler said the plan she believes the anti-abortion movement is working toward
now is similar to one that's worked in the past. When the U.S. Supreme Court
overturned the constitutional right to abortion, Justice Brett Kavanaugh wrote a
concurring opinion, in which he pointed to states that had laws on the books
against abortion access.

"In recent years, a significant number of States have enacted abortion
restrictions that directly conflict with Roe. Those laws cannot be dismissed as
political stunts or as outlier laws," Kavanaugh wrote. "Those numerous state
laws collectively represent the sincere and deeply held views of tens of
millions of Americans."

Enlarge this image

Andrew Shirvell (center in sunglasses) is founder of the anti-abortion group
Florida Voice for the Unborn. He's standing on the steps of the Florida Supreme
Court protesting abortion access. He said if Florida passes a bill letting
parents collect damages for the loss of a pregnancy it would give abortion
opponents another law to point to in the effort to establish fetal personhood in
the state. Regan McCarthy hide caption

toggle caption
Regan McCarthy


Andrew Shirvell (center in sunglasses) is founder of the anti-abortion group
Florida Voice for the Unborn. He's standing on the steps of the Florida Supreme
Court protesting abortion access. He said if Florida passes a bill letting
parents collect damages for the loss of a pregnancy it would give abortion
opponents another law to point to in the effort to establish fetal personhood in
the state.

Regan McCarthy


A FLORIDA BILL IS PAUSED FOR THIS SESSION, BUT NOT GONE FOR GOOD

Florida Republican lawmakers recently considered a bill that would have let
parents collect damages in civil suits for the loss of a pregnancy. While the
bill's sponsors (who helped to pass Florida's pending six-week abortion ban)
said the wrongful death measure had nothing to do with abortion, advocates on
both sides of the issue disagreed.

Andrew Shirvell, founder of the group Florida Voice for the Unborn, told
lawmakers as he spoke about the bill in committee that he would "say the quiet
part out loud." From his viewpoint, he said, the wrongful death bill is "another
reaffirmation that unborn children should be considered nothing less than human
persons under our state laws and our state constitution."

Opponents worried the measure could cut off access to reproductive health care
including abortion and IVF, even though the measure included a definition for
the term "unborn child" that specified it must be in the womb. State Senate
Minority Leader Lauren Book raised concerns the measure could be a vehicle to
bring a fetal personhood case before Chief Justice Muñiz.

"When you're tiptoeing and you're delving for personhood, you're coming for it
and it's only a matter of time," Book said. "I think for a long time people
suggested that advocates [and] lawmakers who talked about personhood, coming
after IVF, the abortion battle, that we were somehow hyperbolic or hysterical.
Well, look where we are."



Shortly after the Alabama ruling, the Senate sponsor of Florida's bill pulled
the measure from its final committee stop.

"Although I have worked diligently to respond to questions and concerns, I
understand there is still work that needs to be done," said Republican state
Sen. Erin Grall in a statement. "It is important we get the policy right with an
issue of this significance."

Book said she hopes new attention on the Alabama case and the stalled Florida
bill could spell the end for the push for fetal personhood.

"People across the country are talking about it," Book said. "I think at the end
of the day, Republicans realize this is a problem. This isn't something that
they should be doing."

In the wake of the Alabama ruling, the campaign arm for U.S. Senate Republicans
advised candidates to "clearly and concisely reject" any efforts to restrict
access to IVF.

But already, Republican legislative leaders in Florida have indicated plans to
revisit their wrongful death bill next year—potentially renewing the discussion
surrounding fetal personhood.

 * Abortion policy
 * reproductive health
 * Abortion rights

 * Facebook
 * Flipboard
 * Email






MORE STORIES FROM NPR

NATIONAL

GEORGE SANTOS, EJECTED FROM HOUSE AND FACING FRAUD TRIAL, WILL RUN AGAIN IN N.Y.

CULTURE

'RUST' FILM ARMORER FOUND GUILTY IN DEATH OF CINEMATOGRAPHER

CLIMATE

CORPORATE AMERICA HAS NEW CLIMATE RULES TO FOLLOW, BUT WILL THEY CUT GLOBAL
WARMING?

NATIONAL SECURITY

CHINESE NATIONAL ARRESTED AND CHARGED WITH STEALING AI TRADE SECRETS FROM GOOGLE

EDUCATION

LIBERTY UNIVERSITY FINED $14 MILLION FOR FEDERAL CRIME REPORTING VIOLATIONS

NATIONAL SECURITY

AIR FORCE EMPLOYEE ACCUSED OF SHARING CLASSIFIED INFO ON A DATING WEBSITE


POPULAR ON NPR.ORG

SCIENCE

SCIENTISTS TAKE A STEP CLOSER TO RESURRECTING THE WOOLLY MAMMOTH

ASIA

TAYLOR SWIFT'S SINGAPORE LEG SPURS BAD BLOOD IN SE ASIA. NEIGHBORS CAN'T SHAKE
IT OFF

MOVIES

WARNER BROS. SHELVED 'COYOTE VS. ACME.' HERE'S WHY SOME FINISHED FILMS ARE
MOTHBALLED

TECHNOLOGY

HOW THE PORN BOTS TOOK OVER TWITTER

NATIONAL

DONOR GIVES $40 MILLION FOR YELLOWSTONE NATIONAL PARK EMPLOYEE HOUSING

LATIN AMERICA

GABRIEL GARCÍA MÁRQUEZ'S LAST NOVEL IS PUBLISHED AGAINST HIS WISHES


NPR EDITORS' PICKS

GLOBAL HEALTH

AN ISRAELI RESPONDER'S WORK ON OCT. 7 SHOWS THE CHALLENGES OF INVESTIGATING
ATROCITIES

NATIONAL

WHAT TO KNOW ABOUT THE POLITICAL DEBATE AROUND DAYLIGHT SAVING TIME

SCIENCE

FOR APRIL'S ECLIPSE, GOING FROM 'MEH' TO 'OMG' MIGHT MEAN JUST DRIVING ACROSS
TOWN

RACE

MALCOLM X IS SET TO BE THE FIRST BLACK PERSON IN THE NEBRASKA HALL OF FAME

MOVIES

WHAT TO EXPECT AT THE OSCARS: THE BOMB, THE BOMBSHELL, AND THE POSSIBLE COMEBACK

HEALTH

5 TIPS TO HELP YOU RESET AFTER THE TIME CHANGE



READ & LISTEN

 * Home
 * News
 * Culture
 * Music
 * Podcasts & Shows

CONNECT

 * Newsletters
 * Facebook
 * Instagram
 * Press
 * Public Editor
 * Corrections
 * Contact & Help

ABOUT NPR

 * Overview
 * Diversity
 * NPR Network
 * Accessibility
 * Ethics
 * Finances

GET INVOLVED

 * Support Public Radio
 * Sponsor NPR
 * NPR Careers
 * NPR Shop
 * NPR Events
 * NPR Extra

 * Terms of Use
 * Privacy
 * Your Privacy Choices
 * Text Only
 * © 2024 npr




Sponsor Message

Become an NPR sponsor



By clicking “Accept All Cookies” or continuing, you agree to the use of cookies,
similar tracking and storage technologies, and information about your device to
enhance your viewing, listening and user experience, personalize content,
personalize messages from NPR’s sponsors, provide social media features, and
analyze NPR’s traffic. This information is shared with social media,
sponsorship, analytics, and other vendors or service providers. You may
customize which cookies you accept in "Cookie Settings."
Cookies Settings Accept All Cookies



PRIVACY PREFERENCE CENTER

NPR and our service providers and vendors use cookies and similar technologies
to collect information. A cookie is a string of characters that can be written
to a file on the user's computer or device when the user visits a site,
application, platform or service. When you visit a website or use a mobile
application, a computer asks your computer or mobile device for permission to
store this file on your computer or mobile device and access information from
it. Information gathered through cookies may include the date and time of visits
and how you are using the website. Note that if you disable or delete cookies,
you may lose access to certain features of the NPR Services.
User ID: d7b03778-b57b-4ea4-9006-37c57cc52977
This User ID will be used as a unique identifier while storing and accessing
your preferences for future.
Timestamp: --
Allow All


MANAGE CONSENT PREFERENCES

STRICTLY NECESSARY OR ESSENTIAL COOKIES

Always Active

These cookies are essential to provide you with services available through the
NPR Services and to enable you to use some of their features. For example, these
cookies allow NPR to remember your registration information while you are logged
in. Local station customization, the NPR Shop, and other interactive features
also use cookies. Without these cookies, the services that you have asked for
cannot be provided, and we only use these cookies to provide you with those
services.

PERFORMANCE AND ANALYTICS COOKIES

Performance and Analytics Cookies

These cookies are used to collect information about traffic to our Services and
how users interact with the NPR Services. The information collected includes the
number of visitors to the NPR Services, the websites that referred visitors to
the NPR Services, the pages that they visited on the NPR Services, what time of
day they visited the NPR Services, whether they have visited the NPR Services
before, and other similar information. We use this information to help operate
the NPR Services more efficiently, to gather broad demographic information and
to monitor the level of activity on the NPR Services.

FUNCTIONAL COOKIES

Functional Cookies

These cookies allow our Services to remember choices you make when you use them,
such as remembering your Member station preferences and remembering your account
details. The purpose of these cookies is to provide you with a more personal
experience and to prevent you from having to re-enter your preferences every
time you visit the NPR Services.

TARGETING AND SPONSOR COOKIES

Targeting and Sponsor Cookies

These cookies track your browsing habits or other information, such as location,
to enable us to show sponsorship credits which are more likely to be of interest
to you. These cookies use information about your browsing history to group you
with other users who have similar interests. Based on that information, and with
our permission, we and our sponsors can place cookies to enable us or our
sponsors to show sponsorship credits and other messages that we think will be
relevant to your interests while you are using third-party services.

Back Button


COOKIE LIST



Search Icon
Filter Icon

Clear
checkbox label label
Apply Cancel
Consent Leg.Interest
checkbox label label
checkbox label label
checkbox label label

Reject All Confirm My Choices