www.vice.com Open in urlscan Pro
151.101.2.133  Public Scan

Form analysis
2 forms found in the DOM

<form><label class="sr-only" for="search-bar__input">Input for searching articles, videos, shows</label><input type="text" id="search-bar__input" role="searchbox" value="" placeholder="Search articles, videos, shows" required=""><button type="submit"
    role="button" aria-label="Search" class="nav-bar__search-bar__button"><svg width="16" height="16" viewBox="0 0 16 16" fill="none" xmlns="http://www.w3.org/2000/svg">
      <path fill-rule="evenodd" clip-rule="evenodd"
        d="M6.55892 10.7328C8.86408 10.7328 10.7328 8.86408 10.7328 6.55892C10.7328 4.25376 8.86408 2.38506 6.55892 2.38506C4.25376 2.38506 2.38506 4.25376 2.38506 6.55892C2.38506 8.86408 4.25376 10.7328 6.55892 10.7328ZM6.55892 13.1178C10.1813 13.1178 13.1178 10.1813 13.1178 6.55892C13.1178 2.93653 10.1813 0 6.55892 0C2.93653 0 0 2.93653 0 6.55892C0 10.1813 2.93653 13.1178 6.55892 13.1178Z"
        fill="white"></path>
      <path fill-rule="evenodd" clip-rule="evenodd" d="M14.5219 15.9015C14.3906 16.0328 14.1777 16.0328 14.0464 15.9015L9.18249 11.0376L11.0376 9.18249L15.9015 14.0464C16.0328 14.1777 16.0328 14.3906 15.9015 14.5219L14.5219 15.9015Z" fill="white">
      </path>
    </svg></button></form>

<form class="article-newsletter-signup__form"><input type="email" name="email" id="email" class="article-newsletter-signup__input" placeholder="Your email" value=""><label class="user-newsletter__form__label" for="email">Your Email:</label> <button
    class="article-newsletter-signup__submit" type="submit">Subscribe</button></form>

Text Content

Advertisement


+ English


VICE
 * Watch
 * World News
 * Canadian News
 * Tech
 * Entertainment
 * Take Care
 * Food
 * Health
 * Drugs
 * LGBTQ
 * Election 2021
 * Opinion
 * Travel
 * Sports
 * Games
 * NSFW
 * Photos
 * Shop Merch
 * Magazine

VICE
 * 
 * 
 * 

 * Watch

Input for searching articles, videos, shows
 * 
 * 
 * 
 * 
 * 
 * 
 * 
 * 

 * World News
 * Canadian News
 * Tech
 * Entertainment
 * Take Care
 * Food
 * Health
 * Drugs
 * LGBTQ
 * Election 2021
 * Opinion
 * Travel
 * Sports
 * Games
 * NSFW
 * Photos
 * Shop Merch
 * Magazine

 * About
 * Careers at VICE
 * VICE Voices
 * Partner
 * VICE Canada Website Terms and Conditions
 * Political Ads Registry
 * Accessibility Statement
 * 

© 2023 VICE MEDIA GROUP



'EYES EVERYWHERE': CONGRESS IS ABOUT TO VOTE TO EXPAND MASS SURVEILLANCE OF
AMERICANS, EXPERTS WARN


Privacy experts worry that a proposed reform bill would greatly widen how the
government can surveil Americans’ digital communications.
by Jules Roscoe
December 11, 2023, 1:00pm
 * Share
 * Tweet
 * Snap

Image: 
Bloomberg Creative via Getty Images

Update: The FISA Reform and Reauthorization Act of 2023 and a competing bill
were both pulled by the House after backlash in a “dramatic showdown.” Read more
here.

The U.S. House Intelligence Committee has proposed a reform bill that privacy
experts are warning would significantly expand the government’s mass
surveillance apparatus. 

You may also like
00:05 / 00:28

How to Treat Sugar Babies
3E3C0


Advertisement


The Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act (FISA) Reform and Reauthorization Act
would be the “biggest expansion of surveillance inside the United States since
the Patriot Act,” which was implemented in the wake of the 9/11 attack to combat
terrorism, said Elizabeth Goitein, the co-director of the Liberty and National
Security Program at the Brennan Center for Justice.

“There would be eyes everywhere,” Goitein told Motherboard in a phone call. “Any
entity that you visit as a customer, that provides Wi-Fi service, could be
required to let the government tap into its equipment, and pull out entire
streams of communications.” 

The Brennan Center for Justice and the Electronic Privacy Information Center
(EPIC) issued a joint statement on Sunday deeming the bill a “wolf in sheep’s
clothing” that would target businesses “far outside the tech sector” that “do
not even have access to communications,” like libraries. The reform bill is
scheduled for a floor vote on Tuesday at 4 p.m. 

The bill reauthorizes FISA Section 702. Section 702 lets the government compel
U.S. communications companies to assist in surveilling non-U.S. individuals who
are outside the country, to account for the fact that “many terrorists and other
foreign adversaries were using email accounts serviced by U.S. companies.”
However, there is a history of documented abuses of Section 702 by U.S. agencies
to spy on citizens who are communicating with someone abroad. 

Advertisement


“Section 702 was designed to allow the government to warrantlessly surveil
non-U.S. citizens abroad for foreign intelligence purposes,” wrote India
McKinney, the director of federal affairs at the Electronic Frontier Foundation
(EFF), in an article last week. “Increasingly, it’s this U.S. side of digital
conversations that domestic law enforcement agencies trawl through—all without a
warrant. FBI agents have been using the Section 702 databases to conduct
millions of invasive searches for Americans’ communications, including those of
protesters, racial justice activists, 19,000 donors to a congressional campaign,
journalists, and even members of Congress.” 

Advertisement


Experts point to one provision in the FISA Reform and Reauthorization Act  as
evidence that it could lead to a massive expansion of the U.S. domestic
surveillance apparatus. It expands the definition of “electronic communication
service provider”—the entities which the government can compel to assist in
surveillance, such as an email service—to include any “equipment that is being
or may be used to transmit or store such communications.” 

Both EPIC and the Brennan Center are warning that this could be as basic as an
ordinary Wi-Fi router at a cafe or library. 

“Any business that has access to ‘equipment’ on which communications are stored
and transmitted would be fair game,” the organizations’ joint statement reads.
“That means hotels, libraries, coffee shops, and other businesses that provide
wifi could be compelled to serve as surrogate spies, structuring their systems
so that they can give the government access to entire communications streams.
Conscripting U.S. business into intelligence agencies’ service was a feature of
the 2007 Protect America Act; Congress explicitly and appropriately rejected
this feature one year later when it passed Section 702.” 

Chris Baumohl, a law fellow at EPIC, said that numerous organizations had signed
a letter to the Senate demanding that the provision not be authorized. 

Advertisement


“It is truly baffling, given the bipartisan consensus that real reforms are
needed, that the House Intelligence Committee would release a bill that reads
more like an intelligence agency wishlist,” Baumohl told Motherboard. “It is not
a good look for your reform bill to do more to expand and entrench
surveillance.” 

Goitein explained that despite the fact that Section 702 was designed to target
non-U.S. individuals, the new provision would mean an increase in surveillance
on Americans, too. 

“Because the government would be able to conduct so much more surveillance,
there would also be more incidental collection of Americans’ communications,”
Goitein said. “When the government is targeting foreigners overseas, it is
inevitably sweeping in Americans communications as well, because Americans
communicate with foreigners. Once you put that surveillance on steroids—which is
what this provision would do—the government would be pulling in orders of
magnitude more of Americans’ communications than it's doing right now.” 

Congress previously reauthorized the bill in 2013 and again in 2018. Its
authorization is currently set to expire on December 31, and the need for
warrantless surveillance reform drove the House committee to propose a set of
changes. The new bill would extend it to 2031. 

“We are proud to put forward this comprehensive, bipartisan legislation to
reduce future abuses, increase accountability for non-compliance, and modernize
the 702 program to most effectively meet our current intelligence needs,” said
committee chairman Mike Turner and ranking member Jim Himes in a statement. “If
enacted, this legislation would be the most extensive and transformative reforms
to the FBI and FISA since the statute was first enacted.” 

The committee’s statement on the matter does not note the revision around
redefining service providers. 

The House Judiciary Committee is sponsoring a second bill, known as the Protect
Liberty and End Warrantless Surveillance Act, that would renew Section 702
without adding provisions that would increase surveillance. Both this and the
Intelligence Committee’s bill will be voted on on Tuesday, with whichever
achieves the most support going into effect.

Tagged:mass surveillanceprivacyintelligence committeeFBIgovernment


SUBSCRIBE TO THE VICE NEWSLETTER.

Your Email: Subscribe
By signing up to the VICE newsletter you agree to receive electronic
communications from VICE that may sometimes include advertisements or sponsored
content.



MORE


LIKE THIS

 * Tech
   
   
   AN ANONYMOUS WEALTHY DONOR IS NOW FUNDING A BASIC CITY SERVICE IN NYC
   
   A New York City group operating community composting drop-offs has been
   temporarily saved from Mayor Eric Adams’ budget cuts thanks to an anonymous,
   wealthy donor.
   
   Roshan Abraham
   12.14.23
   
 * Tech
   
   
   I LIVED IN TEXAS FOR 35 YEARS. HERE’S WHY ALEX GARLAND’S ‘CIVIL WAR’ MAKES
   PERFECT SENSE
   
   The politics and populations of Texas and California are more closely aligned
   than you could possibly imagine.
   
   Matthew Gault
   12.14.23
   
 * Tech
   
   
   TECH BILLIONAIRES LAUNCH FUND TO CREATE NEW LIBERTARIAN SOCIETIES
   
   The Balaji Fund, backed by Coinbase CEO Brian Armstrong and other wealthy
   tech players, aims to fund “Network States” free of overbearing regulations.
   
   Jordan Pearson
   12.14.23
   
 * Tech
   
   
   MAN IN CHARGE OF INFLICTING PAIN ON U.S. ECONOMY INDICATES HE MIGHT FINALLY
   BE SATISFIED
   
   Fed Chairman Jerome Powell made an announcement on interest rate hikes that
   have fueled layoffs and made houses pricier. Here's what you should know.
   
   Maxwell Strachan
   12.14.23
   
 * Tech
   
   
   THE OLD INTERNET IS DYING, AND SOMETHING WORSE IS BEING BORN
   
   As the web declines, we pause to talk about the death of criticism and what
   happens when someone rips off your work.
   
   Matthew Gault
   12.14.23
   

Advertisement





YOUMAY LIKE
Skip
Ads by

Learn More

Here Are 23 Of The Coolest Gifts For Christmas 2023 Advertisement: Coolest Gifts
2023

Ad is Hidden
Please tell us why you hid this ad?
 * Inappropriate
 * Misleading
 * Misinformation
 * Repetitive
 * Irrelevant
 * Distracting


Windows Users Didn't Know This Simple Trick To Block All Ads (Do It Now)
Removing ads is the first step in having a faster, safer and hassle-free
browsing experience! Advertisement: Safe Tech Tips

Ad is Hidden
Please tell us why you hid this ad?
 * Inappropriate
 * Misleading
 * Misinformation
 * Repetitive
 * Irrelevant
 * Distracting


Only $49 to get all the TV channels? It's now possible Advertisement: TV
Superboost

Ad is Hidden
Please tell us why you hid this ad?
 * Inappropriate
 * Misleading
 * Misinformation
 * Repetitive
 * Irrelevant
 * Distracting


Alaska Cruises Going For Great Deals Now Advertisement: StartSearch| Search Ads

Ad is Hidden
Please tell us why you hid this ad?
 * Inappropriate
 * Misleading
 * Misinformation
 * Repetitive
 * Irrelevant
 * Distracting


1 Cup of This Daily Burns Pounds of Fat! Try Tonight Advertisement: Health Today
News

Ad is Hidden
Please tell us why you hid this ad?
 * Inappropriate
 * Misleading
 * Misinformation
 * Repetitive
 * Irrelevant
 * Distracting


What’s my car worth? Online Calculator for Car Resale find out the value in a
few clicks of cars and motorcycles Advertisement: TrendingResults

Ad is Hidden
Please tell us why you hid this ad?
 * Inappropriate
 * Misleading
 * Misinformation
 * Repetitive
 * Irrelevant
 * Distracting


Awesome New Hearing Aids Sweeping Canada Advertisement: Best Hearing Aids

Ad is Hidden
Please tell us why you hid this ad?
 * Inappropriate
 * Misleading
 * Misinformation
 * Repetitive
 * Irrelevant
 * Distracting


Toronto: Unsold Repossessed Cars Sell For Almost Nothing (Take A Look)
Advertisement: Repossessed Cars | Search Ads

Ad is Hidden
Please tell us why you hid this ad?
 * Inappropriate
 * Misleading
 * Misinformation
 * Repetitive
 * Irrelevant
 * Distracting





MORE


FROM VICE

 * Tech
   
   
   RED ALERT: SCIENTISTS HAVE DISCOVERED A DOLPHIN WITH THUMBS
   
   I, for one, welcome our dolphin overlords.
   
   Jordan Pearson
   12.13.23
   
 * Tech
   
   
   TESLA UPDATING AUTOPILOT IN NEARLY EVERY CAR IN U.S. AFTER INVESTIGATION INTO
   CRASHES
   
   The update will ensure drivers using the company's so-called “autopilot,”
   which is not autonomous, remain in control of the vehicle.
   
   Aaron Gordon
   12.13.23
   
 * Tech
   
   
   TESLA UPDATING AUTOPILOT IN NEARLY EVERY CAR IN U.S. AFTER INVESTIGATION INTO
   CRASHES
   
   The update will ensure drivers using the company's so-called “Autopilot,”
   which is not autonomous, remain in control of the vehicle.
   
   Aaron Gordon
   12.13.23
   
 * Tech
   
   
   A U.S. POLITICIAN IS ROBOCALLING VOTERS WITH AN AI CHATBOT NAMED ‘ASHLEY’
   
   Pennsylvania Democrat Shemaine Daniels’ campaign for the House is the first
   to use AI to seek a Congressional seat.
   
   Janus Rose
   12.12.23
   
 * Tech
   
   
   CONGRESS PULLS BILL THAT WOULD MASSIVELY EXPAND SURVEILLANCE AFTER 'DRAMATIC
   SHOWDOWN'
   
   The House was set to vote on two competing bills reauthorizing a powerful
   mass surveillance tool, but faced backlash from rights groups.
   
   Jules Roscoe
   12.12.23
   
 * Tech
   
   
   ANTI-WAR WORKERS BLOCKADE FACTORY MAKING ISRAELI DRONE ENGINES FOR ITS SIEGE
   ON GAZA
   
   World Beyond War blocked the entrance of a Pratt & Whitney plant in Canada
   this morning.
   
   Matthew Gault
   12.12.23
   

Advertisement





 * About
 * Careers at VICE
 * VICE Voices
 * Partner
 * VICE Canada Website Terms and Conditions
 * Political Ads Registry
 * Accessibility Statement
 * 

© 2023 VICE MEDIA GROUP